Convincing John
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Aug 27, 2003
- Messages
- 1,243
- Reaction score
- 195
I know this thread is about ninjas, so I don't want to get off topic too much. Maybe another thread can be started about school and our experiences.
I agree with Dr Tooth about how kids feel towards school and I had pretty much the same attitude, experience and even some teachers like Bart's kindergarten teacher. "F, Bart and believe me, you'll be seeing plenty of them." Speaking of the Simpsons, Matt Groening's earlier comic strip featuring rabbits sums it up quite nicely in one particular book I can't type the name of here. It begins "School is..." and you'll see a one-eared rabbit on the front doing a Bart Simpson chalkboard gag...only what the rabbit is writing has a lot more "bite" than what Bart writes. I would highly recommend this book, actually...if you really want to know what school was like for me and apparently a lot of other kids, too.
I can speak about my own cynicism about school in general from both sides of the desk. I clearly remember what it was like to be a student and I was also a teacher for three years. There's a lot I could talk about, but how do I simplify it?
Since this is a Forum about Jim Henson and Henson-related topics in general and since we're discussing education, I'll zero in on a couple of key examples from when I was a kid:
Did you know the macaw doesn't exist? According to my first grade teacher, it's true. I was stayed home from school one day in first grade due to a cold. I watched Mister Rogers' Neighborhood that day and Mister McFeely had a macaw to show Mister Rogers. Yes, a real one. Mr McFeely gave a few facts about it, he fed it something (seeds?) and as they did on Mister Rogers' Neighborhood, they made sure to have some lingering close ups of it so little kids could really see it. Here's the proof: episode 1243, folks:
http://www.neighborhoodarchive.com/mrn/episodes/1243/index.html
The next day in school, the class was naming different types of birds for some mural we were making. "Cardinal!" "Robin!" "Canary!" "Ostrich!" "Penguin!" answered the kids. When the teacher called on me, I said "Macaw". The class looked at me like I was crazy and so did the teacher.
"A what?"
"A macaw," I repeated. "it's red, yellow and blue and about this big..." I held my hands about two feet apart.
"Oh, there's no bird like that!" snapped the teacher. The kids around me laughed and looked at me like I was an idiot. Now I know how Big Bird felt when he tried to prove Snuffy existed all those years!
"But...I saw it...it has a long tail and...it talks..." I noticed the set of picture encyclopedias on the far shelf. I was one of the best readers in the class and I knew if I had the "M" volume, I could find that bird easily. "I can show you in the..." I pointed to the books.
"No!" snapped the teacher. "it doesn't exist! Stay in your seat. Now, who can tell me the name of a real bird?"
"Pigeon!" "Chickadee!" "Parakeet!" "Parrot!" the class continued. Several of them looked at me and smirked as though I were an idiot. (Ironically, no one had trouble accepting the parrot as real, but not an "imaginary" type of parrot).
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Same grade, different first grade teacher (we rotated between 3 teachers daily), different scenario, and still relating to PBS:
There's something Sesame Street-related that I don't know has ever been discussed on this forum. We talk a lot about Sesame Street (and some Electric Company) clips, but I wondered what kind of research goes behind the typography. It doesn't matter if it's a 3D or 2D letter or number. Sesame Street is researched very heavily (as we know), so I just wondered who (if anyone) decided what the letters and numbers should look like on the show.
Think of the types of fonts we use and read regularly. This is a four:
And this is a four:
So, which one is "right"? We don't think about it much as adults, but when you're a kid and you want to print your letters and numbers right, which source do you trust: Sesame Street or what the teacher says?
Both types of the number four have been simultaneously shown on Sesame Street. The "open top" 4 (like the one above) was displayed above our chalkboard on the traditional green classroom banner, along with the rest of the numbers and the alphabet.
However, the "closed top" 4 was right there on every computer keyboard in the same classroom (and the neighbor's house numbers we could see from the classroom window). The OCR A Extended font gives a perfect example of the four I was taught to write.
There's an old Sesame Street clip about the letter "t", which describes it as "sort of a fish hook with a line through it". The way we wrote a lowercase "t" in grade school had no "fish hook". It just looked like a cross. Was this "fish hook" acceptable in some areas in the 1970's? The clip was relatively new when I was learning to write, so a "t" that looked like a crossed-out, backwards, capital "J" made me go "...what the heck?" Granted, some Sesame Street clips made lots of us go "what the heck?" but they were often nonsensical, "gaint-rabbit-chases-kids" type of stuff. But when a clip specifically says "this letter of the alphabet looks like this" and contradicts examples you know, (and even itself in the same show) that's a whole other type of head scratcher.
There are a couple of other typography examples which confused us in class (or at least me). We were one of the lucky classes that got to watch The Electric Company (1970's version) in school. At that time, we were learning how to make apostrophes, commas and quotation marks. It was all well and good, but I got in trouble for not making mine "right". The apostrophe was "supposed" to be round and curved (like a piece of popcorn shrimp). I made mine like the ones I saw on The Electric Company: a box with a little triangle hanging down. So...which one was right?
Lowercase "g" caused me a huge amount of embarrassment one time in that same class. Anyone remember those stupid worksheets printed with that fuzzy, purple ink you could barely read? Well, we had a "g" lesson one day where we got worksheets with pictures on them and another worksheet with fuzzy, purple, printed 'g's' on it. We were supposed to cut out the 'g's and glue them to the things that started with 'g' in that picture.
Now, we had been taught to write the lowercase letter g that resembled an Arial font: g. However, the company that made the worksheets had Times New Roman g's. Look at these g's side by side: g g.
I lost one of my 'g' cards during the activity and quickly used a scrap of paper and a purple colored pencil to make a replacement before the teacher found out. Instead of making the "Arial" g, I made a Times New Roman g to match the others because I didn't want to get in trouble. Before I could glue it to the picture of the gorilla, the teacher saw it, grabbed it and held it up for the whole class to see.
"IS THIS HOW WE MAKE OUR G'S?" she bellowed to the whole class.
"NO!" the class shouted back.
Then why are they like that on the worksheets, then??? I thought furiously. Furthermore, the "g" I made was a lot more legible than the ones from the ditto machine. What made me the most upset was this: why did the teacher feel the need to humiliate a student, when the student was just trying to correct a mistake?
So, that's just a couple of examples. My experience as a teacher was excruciating. I won't sugar coat that at all. I let my teaching license lapse after 3 years, switched careers and I never looked back. If anyone has any questions, I'll tell those tales in another thread, since this one's technically about kids liking ninja shows. Sorry if I took the thread off topic.
I agree with Dr Tooth about how kids feel towards school and I had pretty much the same attitude, experience and even some teachers like Bart's kindergarten teacher. "F, Bart and believe me, you'll be seeing plenty of them." Speaking of the Simpsons, Matt Groening's earlier comic strip featuring rabbits sums it up quite nicely in one particular book I can't type the name of here. It begins "School is..." and you'll see a one-eared rabbit on the front doing a Bart Simpson chalkboard gag...only what the rabbit is writing has a lot more "bite" than what Bart writes. I would highly recommend this book, actually...if you really want to know what school was like for me and apparently a lot of other kids, too.
I can speak about my own cynicism about school in general from both sides of the desk. I clearly remember what it was like to be a student and I was also a teacher for three years. There's a lot I could talk about, but how do I simplify it?
Since this is a Forum about Jim Henson and Henson-related topics in general and since we're discussing education, I'll zero in on a couple of key examples from when I was a kid:
Did you know the macaw doesn't exist? According to my first grade teacher, it's true. I was stayed home from school one day in first grade due to a cold. I watched Mister Rogers' Neighborhood that day and Mister McFeely had a macaw to show Mister Rogers. Yes, a real one. Mr McFeely gave a few facts about it, he fed it something (seeds?) and as they did on Mister Rogers' Neighborhood, they made sure to have some lingering close ups of it so little kids could really see it. Here's the proof: episode 1243, folks:
http://www.neighborhoodarchive.com/mrn/episodes/1243/index.html
The next day in school, the class was naming different types of birds for some mural we were making. "Cardinal!" "Robin!" "Canary!" "Ostrich!" "Penguin!" answered the kids. When the teacher called on me, I said "Macaw". The class looked at me like I was crazy and so did the teacher.
"A what?"
"A macaw," I repeated. "it's red, yellow and blue and about this big..." I held my hands about two feet apart.
"Oh, there's no bird like that!" snapped the teacher. The kids around me laughed and looked at me like I was an idiot. Now I know how Big Bird felt when he tried to prove Snuffy existed all those years!
"But...I saw it...it has a long tail and...it talks..." I noticed the set of picture encyclopedias on the far shelf. I was one of the best readers in the class and I knew if I had the "M" volume, I could find that bird easily. "I can show you in the..." I pointed to the books.
"No!" snapped the teacher. "it doesn't exist! Stay in your seat. Now, who can tell me the name of a real bird?"
"Pigeon!" "Chickadee!" "Parakeet!" "Parrot!" the class continued. Several of them looked at me and smirked as though I were an idiot. (Ironically, no one had trouble accepting the parrot as real, but not an "imaginary" type of parrot).
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Same grade, different first grade teacher (we rotated between 3 teachers daily), different scenario, and still relating to PBS:
There's something Sesame Street-related that I don't know has ever been discussed on this forum. We talk a lot about Sesame Street (and some Electric Company) clips, but I wondered what kind of research goes behind the typography. It doesn't matter if it's a 3D or 2D letter or number. Sesame Street is researched very heavily (as we know), so I just wondered who (if anyone) decided what the letters and numbers should look like on the show.
Think of the types of fonts we use and read regularly. This is a four:
And this is a four:
So, which one is "right"? We don't think about it much as adults, but when you're a kid and you want to print your letters and numbers right, which source do you trust: Sesame Street or what the teacher says?
Both types of the number four have been simultaneously shown on Sesame Street. The "open top" 4 (like the one above) was displayed above our chalkboard on the traditional green classroom banner, along with the rest of the numbers and the alphabet.
However, the "closed top" 4 was right there on every computer keyboard in the same classroom (and the neighbor's house numbers we could see from the classroom window). The OCR A Extended font gives a perfect example of the four I was taught to write.
There's an old Sesame Street clip about the letter "t", which describes it as "sort of a fish hook with a line through it". The way we wrote a lowercase "t" in grade school had no "fish hook". It just looked like a cross. Was this "fish hook" acceptable in some areas in the 1970's? The clip was relatively new when I was learning to write, so a "t" that looked like a crossed-out, backwards, capital "J" made me go "...what the heck?" Granted, some Sesame Street clips made lots of us go "what the heck?" but they were often nonsensical, "gaint-rabbit-chases-kids" type of stuff. But when a clip specifically says "this letter of the alphabet looks like this" and contradicts examples you know, (and even itself in the same show) that's a whole other type of head scratcher.
There are a couple of other typography examples which confused us in class (or at least me). We were one of the lucky classes that got to watch The Electric Company (1970's version) in school. At that time, we were learning how to make apostrophes, commas and quotation marks. It was all well and good, but I got in trouble for not making mine "right". The apostrophe was "supposed" to be round and curved (like a piece of popcorn shrimp). I made mine like the ones I saw on The Electric Company: a box with a little triangle hanging down. So...which one was right?
Lowercase "g" caused me a huge amount of embarrassment one time in that same class. Anyone remember those stupid worksheets printed with that fuzzy, purple ink you could barely read? Well, we had a "g" lesson one day where we got worksheets with pictures on them and another worksheet with fuzzy, purple, printed 'g's' on it. We were supposed to cut out the 'g's and glue them to the things that started with 'g' in that picture.
Now, we had been taught to write the lowercase letter g that resembled an Arial font: g. However, the company that made the worksheets had Times New Roman g's. Look at these g's side by side: g g.
I lost one of my 'g' cards during the activity and quickly used a scrap of paper and a purple colored pencil to make a replacement before the teacher found out. Instead of making the "Arial" g, I made a Times New Roman g to match the others because I didn't want to get in trouble. Before I could glue it to the picture of the gorilla, the teacher saw it, grabbed it and held it up for the whole class to see.
"IS THIS HOW WE MAKE OUR G'S?" she bellowed to the whole class.
"NO!" the class shouted back.
Then why are they like that on the worksheets, then??? I thought furiously. Furthermore, the "g" I made was a lot more legible than the ones from the ditto machine. What made me the most upset was this: why did the teacher feel the need to humiliate a student, when the student was just trying to correct a mistake?
So, that's just a couple of examples. My experience as a teacher was excruciating. I won't sugar coat that at all. I let my teaching license lapse after 3 years, switched careers and I never looked back. If anyone has any questions, I'll tell those tales in another thread, since this one's technically about kids liking ninja shows. Sorry if I took the thread off topic.