minor muppetz said:
This would make a great layout for the set:
Disc 1:
Season 1 premier (with commentary by Caroll Spinney, Joan Ganz Coony, Loretta Long, and Bob McGraph)
Season 2 premier
bonus features:
The Best of Season 1
The Best of Season 2
Sesame Street Promotional Film
Disc 2:
Season 3 premier (with commentary by Caroll Spinney, Sonia Manzano, and Jerry Nelson)
Season 4 premier
bonus features:
The Best of Season 3
The Best of Season 4
Test Pilot #1
Disc 3:
Season 5 premier
The Best of Season 5
Sesame Street Unpaved
And here are what skits I'd include for the best of season compilations. I hope I am right about the years of certain sketches, but these are my best guess. I also hope that I don't accidently list anything that was cut from the Noggin broadcasts of the premier episodes (I am going by how Muppet Wiki lists the skit orders).
The Best of Season 1:
Ernie and Bert split jellybeans
I Love Trash (original version, assuming this was performed in the first season)
Let's Sing a Song of One
Jazzy Spies #4
ABC-DEF-GHI
Ernie and Cookie Monster share a pillow
Pick Your Pet
Near and Far
Sing
Kermit's Milk Lecture
The People in Your Neighborhood
Big Bird meets Little Bird
Let's Sing a Song of Nine
a Buddy and Jim skit
James Earl Jones recites the alphabet
Kermit and Grover talk about the word "In"
Ernie eats Bert's cake
Oscar recites the alphabet
Lefty attempts to sell Ernie a U
Everyone Likes Ice Cream
Goin' for a Ride
Ernie stands on the ceiling and pours milk
Proffessor Hastings lecture on body parts
an Alice Braitswaithe Goodyshoes skit that was not included in The Sesame Street Book of Puzzles (if all three skits from that book were her only appearances, then include the one where she talks about wet and dry)
Jazzy Spies #8
Ernie and Bert's sandbox game
Kermit's rectangle lecture
monsters whisper C
One of These Things
first and last
Lulu's Back in Town
The Best of Season 2
Ernie and Cookie Monster talk about hope
What's My Part?: Foot
Herbert Birdsfoot and Grover count to 20
Lefty attempts to sell Ernie a stop sign
Cookie Monster and the word Amour
a Ralph and Wally skit
X Marks the Spot
Ernie meets Simon Soundman
Roosevelt Franklin's Days of the Week
The King of 8
Mad
Admiral Big Bird
Ernie replaces Bert's cowboy hat with a pan
another Ralph and Wally skit
Harvey Kneeslapper: Do you know where I wanna B?
The Amazing Mumford's disapearing cookie act
Bert accuses Ernie of eating his cookies
Up and Down
The Best of Season 3:
Beat the Time: Cookie Monster
a Jasper and Julius skit
A quart of milk, a loaf of bread, and a stick of butter
Kermit draws a triangle
Grover the Waiter: Hamburger
Funny Farm
The Banana Sketch part 1
Everybody Eats
The Banana Sketch Part 2
Roosevelt Franklin talks to his class about africa
Sesame Street News: The Tortose and the Hare
Penny Candy Man
a Larry and Phyllis skit
Ernie puts the radio knob on Bert
Typewriter Guy: A-Airplane
Grover the Elevador Operador: five people in an elevador
Sesame Street News: Rupunzel
a Larry and Phyllis skit
The Golden An
The Alligator King
Ernie paints a picture of Bert
The Best of Season 4:
Grover the Waiter: no spoon
Sesame Street News: The Count counts Three Little Pigs
Ernie and Bert at the Movies: Ernie gets emotional
The Ballad of Casey McPhee
Beat the Time: Grover
Caveman Sherlock Hemlock invents a toothbrush for Caveman Ernie
Herry Monster and John John count to 20
Grover tries to sell Kermit a pair of earmuffs
Proud
To Tell a Face
I Want a Monster to Be My Friend
Grover the Waiter: The Count
Ernie eats Berts ice cream
The Best of Season 5:
Headball
The Song of The Count
Super Grover: Haircut
Sesame Street News: Alice in Wonderland
The Count stays over at Ernie and Bert's apartment part 1
Kermit, Shala, and Fanny demonstrate "next to"
Count it Higher
The Count stays over at Ernie and Bert's apartment part 2
Four
Let's Make a Face
Kermit talks about feet
Believe in Yourself