Muppets haven't done very well as midseason replacements, but then I fear it'd be even worse if they started at the beginning of the season. Call me crazy, but March-April has never worked out for the Muppets. I hate to say it, but the Muppets might work best as a summer series when there's virtually no competition. The net might give them a chance to grow and keep them in a consistent spot. So I guess if I were running the company, I'd put the Muppets to work right away in a few more TV-movies for NBC (one per sweeps period), all the while developing the Fox series for a launch in summer 2004.
As much as I'd love another theatrical movie (a good one, of course), I think it's still too risky at this point. As I've said, there IS an affection among the general populace for these characters, but too many non-fan people also still have something of a bad taste in their mouth from projects from the past decade. If the "master plan" goes well and the show has a successful run, then I think the next movie would get a big reception after that series goes off the air...even though that wouldn't be till 2009.
I'm not actually in favor of a Muppet Fest this year anymore. Firstly, for selfish reasons, because I have no money even if they were to have another show right now. Secondly, there's no reason for the company to put off working on projects to basically have another nostalgia fest. This is the time for gaining momentum. After they've had several TV-movies and got 13 episodes of the Fox series in the can, they can time MF 2 for 2004, just in time to promote the launch of the new series.
BTW, I'm still in favor of MF 2 in NY with a heavy Sesame theme, as it'll be the 35th anniversary of Sesame. Don't get me wrong, I don't want Elmo to take over the Fest or anything. But I want Caroll Spinney and Fran Brill, etc. to be taking their rightful place alongside the other Muppeteers this time, and I want to hear their insights on their longtime collaboration with the company. I also think a dialogue between Oscar and Pepe would be hysterical.
But all those are, of course, just my thoughts.
Aaron likes Rowlf (can I call you ALR for short?), I'm not sure this thread is entirely done, but if you start a thread about the new series, I'll jump in!