heralde said:
Well, as much as I like continuity, I understand why they'd make adoption a new concept for Big Bird...Kids need to be able to identify with him, go through the same things he's going through. So he really shouldn't get that much more experienced.
I thought Elmo was the one everyone at Sesame Workship wanted kids to identify with
I agree, Big Bird has become more of the big brother, and in the early '90s he was more mature than in the '70s, when he was supposed to be about 4. And, actually, Bear, you're very right about the 3-3.5 phase being a *big* difference. It's about that time that children have a huge, verbal explosion to where they're talking all the time. Some do it a bit earlier, some later, of course. (Sorry, can't figure how to quote 2 different posts - maybe I can't.)
Seriously, in the season 35 openers, wasn't it mentioned that Miles was adopted? I'm almost sure I remember them saying that when Grover was taking Elmo through the past. It was glossed over, just like what happened to Mr. Hooper, but I'm pretty sure they did say that.
Now, here's what I think *could* be argued successfully. Big Bird hsn't heard about adoption in a long time for him. He's not clear on the concept, becasue it's not something he thinks about every day. I recall my one cousin not knowing what divorce was at BB's age (6) and getting it confused with other words he had in his brain, in the category marked "things family's do." (Including adoption - yes, 6YOs can get concepts mixed up like that.)
*So*, to make a long story short, they could very plausibly argue that Big Bird's not clear on the concept. Later (sadly, probably offscreen) he has an "ah-ha" moment where he says, "Oh, yeah, now I remember. Gordon and Susan adopted Miles, too. But - they didn't go to another country to do it." (Another reason why BB could be unclear on the conept - it's not how he remembers hearing of it.)
So, my apologies for the long comment, but it is highly plausible that BB could be at least fuzzy on the concept, and possibly not know it at all. *However*, that being said, to keep continuity they should have the "Ah ha moment" be on screen, like this:
BB: Oh yeah, now I remember. Miles was adopted, too. Only...you and Susan didn't go to another country to get him.
Gordon: That's right, Big Bird, Lots of children need good, loving homes. Gina just chose one from someplace different than we did.