Reading the review again, I noticed that it says that they are introduced by a cartoon character who explains that the episodes may not meet todays educational needs. I wonder why this needed to be mentioned. Do all educational shows need to have the same curriculum (I thought Sesame Workshop chose it's own curriculums for each year)? This makes me wonder if all previously-released Sesame Street videos somehow focused on their current educational needs. I mean, did Sesame Workshop teach kids about babysitting when The Best of Ernie and Bert was made? What main educational needs were followed for the other "best of" character videos (especially Kermit and Grover) and the two anniversary videos?
Also, are the animated introductions annoying in any way? I would much rather just see the old episodes begin as soon as I hit the play button, or I'd rather see an introduction by a muppet (maybe Big Bird or Grover, or even the return of a classic character who isn't used much anymore, like Guy Smiley or The Amazing Mumford). Or better yet, maybe there should have been introductions by performers, cast members, or crew members. It would have been great if Caroll Spinney or Jerry Nelson introduced the episodes.
While the review points out that the bonus skits are mostly stuff we've seen hundreds of times, there are a lot of skits listed that I can't identify any skit with those titles (like Swinging Gibbon, Alphabet Soup, and many others). There are also a lot of skits included that as far as I know weren't shown on Noggin, never released on video (in the U.S., at least), or shown in any new episodes in at least the last five to ten years (again, this is concerning the american version). Has the original version of I love Trash been seen since the first season? Ditto with I've Got Two (I have a feeling that theys topped showing orange Oscar skits after the first season). Out of the season bonus skits, the third season classic cuts feature has the most skits that I know and remember well.
Looking at the still for one of the scene selection menus, it seems interesting that the Baker film for three is listed as Henson #3, instead of baker #3 or Let's Sing a Song of Three. I assume that the chapter stops also list the 2 skit as Henson #2. And I was hoping that chapter stops would refer to the skits by their official titles (if there are official titles), but it seems like most of the titles are pretty much made up. Yes, I am aware that older Sesame Street DVD chapter stops used titles that seem made up as well (Dance Along lists one skit as ABC Disco, but A Celebration of Me, Grover! features that same skit, but lists it as Alphabet Fever).
Finally, is the Big Bird and Grover skit that replaced the store scene the same Big Bird and Grover skit shown on TV in E.T. The Extra Terrestrial?