Wow - I haven't posted here in forever, though I do lurk from time to time.
I've been following this thread pretty closely and enjoyed reading everyone's thoughts about the movie. I think it so refreshing to see people posting thoughts and being respectful even when not agreeing about something. Well done, MuppetCentral! That's Jim Henson's presence coming through loud and clear. It's great to see such a nice community of people interacting civilly (such a cyber-rarity these days)
I finally saw the movie with my 4-year-old daughter over the weekend. She really enjoyed it! I enjoyed it...somewhat. I thought that many of the songs were great (love Brett McKenzie), and Steve Whitmire was fabulous as Kermit! He's just...really come into his own with the character. I laughed a bit during the movie, but not as much as I'd have liked. But my main problem with the movie was it lacked the heart of the original movies or even the 2011 reboot.
I can't remember now who said this, but someone remarked that they forgot they were watching a muppet during the Constantine scenes (of which there were many). I have to concur - Constantine was in no way a muppet, because he was just too vile and selfish of a character. As others have said, that selfishness just spread too easily to the other characters. It was too front and central, held up by a pretty poor premise.
I just...felt like the movie was a bit mean-spirited. Sorry, I'm definitely in that camp, folks. I get that the movie could have been consciously exploring that theme, but the scripting wasn't strong enough for it to hold together. I just missed Kermit's presence through much of the movie, and while that may have been partly the point, it was odd to have a Kermit-like but really nothing-like-Kermit character in the limelight for so much of the movie.
The characters just didn't always seem true to themselves. I though Fozzie was off. Piggy was okay, but...she needed to realize what was going on with Constantine sooner. Why did it physically require both Kermits in front of her talking for her to recognize what was up? Seemed like sloppy writing - not true to the characters. It makes me a little worried that the Muppets will go back to becoming caricatures of themselves like they were in the late 90's and 00's. I really hope that doesn't happen.
I agree with heralde about the Gulag scenes being some of the best. Loved Tina Fey, the chain gang, Kermit. Unlike many of you, I felt like the Sam the Eagle and Ty Burrell scenes fell a bit flat. Perhaps this will change on subsequent viewings, I dunno.
On a positive note, the theater where I saw MMW was practically sold out! My daughter had to sit on my lap. This was a Sunday matinee, and mind you, the movie has been out for a while now. Still, I'm sorry to hear that it hasn't been doing better in the box office.
One great bit, I loved - Stanley Tucci's cameo! That really got me guffawing!