ISNorden
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2006
- Messages
- 1,294
- Reaction score
- 54
After two well-written storylines, the one used for today's episode disappointed me badly; the basic "Elmo gets obsessed with a book and manipulates another friend into reading it" plot has been used hundreds of times. And two versions of the same "In My Book" song on two consecutive days? Despite Bert and Ernie's being involved the second time, that was another letdown; I bet even a kindergarten kid who follows the show would notice and feel bored. Finally, the "school" theme tacked on to the last few minutes seemed like an afterthought; I was glad to see the episode end.
The ending itself, at least, was a highlight: there hasn't been an ending without the "bedtime story" framework since the Season 36 finale. Capturing a letter and a number from actual clips on the show was pretty clever, too: if Abby had to remember them, she'd obviously think back to some clip on the show.
Overall, I'd give #4138 a 2 on a scale of 1-10. Not every episode can be as memorable or "old-style" as the first three, but I hope that the rest of the season won't turn out so badly.
The ending itself, at least, was a highlight: there hasn't been an ending without the "bedtime story" framework since the Season 36 finale. Capturing a letter and a number from actual clips on the show was pretty clever, too: if Abby had to remember them, she'd obviously think back to some clip on the show.
Overall, I'd give #4138 a 2 on a scale of 1-10. Not every episode can be as memorable or "old-style" as the first three, but I hope that the rest of the season won't turn out so badly.