Ok, so I started a separate thread and was then pointed out to this one. I am very split, but am also very miffed, mostly about the pitch reel. When it is advertised on the cover, and included obviously as a treat to the diehards like some of us, THIS should be left untouched. It is a huge slap in the face of Jim Henson's creative genius to leave out that one last line. Sure, the thing holds up without it, but being that this is and will most likely forever be the only commercially available form of it, it is very unfair to release it as such. It serves as a tremendous tease. It's as if some long lost Stooges movie or say an Abbot and Costello bit was discovered and "fully restored and remastered from the original footage", but leaving you with only Abbot saying "Say, who was that lady I saw you with, last night?", with COstello's response. I don't usually get so stereotypically angry geeky, but this IS the Muppets, and that is butchery, pure and simple.
The in-show cuts I could deal with a bit better, though it all still seems to go against the promise of being fully restored or whatever. I guess the war on piracy isn't such a big deal of studios with all the money in the world won't do everything in their massive power to make the stuff available. I'd pay upwards of fifty bucks a season if it was completely unedited, as was originally broadcast, even without extras. Well, maybe not COMPLETELY lacking extras, but with NO coming attractions and commercials for Disney-owned movies and TV shows. People don't buy DVDs to find out what is coming soon to theaters, because when they have those DVDs twenty years later, they won't be. It makes me wish I knew DVD coding so I could bring my Time-Life Vincent Price into the Disney one's rightful chronological placing, though I still want to hear Uncle Deadly say "Guy Lombardo" to match his mouth.
Let's all demand that the full pitch and other vintage Muppet stuff make it to shelves, what do you say? No cuts! I smell a petition a-brewin'!
-Squigiman