The all-time scariest for me...
'toons/live action:
"G - Gorilla" this scared the living **** out of me as a kid 'cuz when that one guy unzipped his costume to reveal he was a gorilla, he made this unearthly noise (AAAUUGHGHHEYYYAARRHHAAGGGHH!!!), and plus I thought that the gorilla was EATING the guy in the costume.
Bellhop cartoon with 8 steamer trunks/suitcases - I still wish someone would post this on YouTube for the "scare factor" it gave me, which was that he fainted (I think) when he got to the 8th floor and that all the suitcases fell on his head.
"Milk, Mi-ilk, Milk" For 2 reasons - # 1 was that I was really sleepy at the time I first saw this one so I thought I just made it up, # 2 was Blossom Dearie's INCREDIBLY high voice (still wondering why the Singing Orange never gave me the creeps as a kid
)
"40 Dots" - Anyone who was scared of skits where people screamed REALLY loudly was probably scared of this one. BTW, someone needs to post not only this one, but the counting to 14 elephant I've heard so much about on here, it sounds very similar (since they both get irrationally tense and anxious when it comes to a certain number) I have a very foggy memory of "40 Dots", but I think the screaming in that one is comparable to that of (the chorus to) "Institutionalized" by Suicidal Tendencies.
Muppet skits (these are rarer, usually I liked the Muppets):
Frazzle - what kid WASN'T scared of this guy?!? I thought he was the devil back when I was a wee lad.
"Big Kids Cry" someone NEEDS to repost this on YouTube, for I enjoyed seeing not only how silly I was for being scared of it, but also just how silly the song was (lyrically it's the first emo song
) Anyway, it scared me because of the "Boo-hoo, wah-wah, sob-sob, (blowing noses)" part, which somehow led me to believe those kids were misbehaving (yep, I was such a weirdo back then)
"I Cry" by Rocky - then again maybe I was just scared of ANY skit that dealt with crying, though this one probably got on my nerves a bit more than the previous one because of the "WAAAAAAAAA-AAAAAAAAAAHHH!!!" noise at the beginning. Nowadays I can't get enough of it, and everytime I see it, I think to myself, "This must've been what Joey Ramone was like as a baby!"