The animated sketch from SS that used to scare me in my youth was Splasho the Diver. I think I remember seeing that in the late 80's episodes and on the Season 25 shows. The part that scared me was where Splasho yelled "BEFORE!" to the cleaner. I'm dying to see it so it won't be scary anymore!!!
The Typewriter Guy U-Umbrella used to scare me when I was a little kid. Now, when I watched a Sesame Street Re-paved episode from 2000 on Noggin where Big Bird and Snuffy having a rainy day picnic, it was not scary anymore!
A newly animated sketch from the late 80's that scared me was where a purple cat tries to sleep as the kid's voice writes the incomplete sentence "My cat is..." in first-grade writing and in improper language. The scene that scared me the most was when the sentence was "My cat iz", the cat uses its orange tongue to erase it!!!
I used to run away from that in my youth. Now, as I watched a Sesame Street Re-paved episode from 2000 on Noggin where Elizabeth is looking for pet cat, Little Murray Sparkles, it didn't scare me!
Also, in my youth, I used to get scared of the sketch where Telly forms any different scary animal costumes. I think he uses his imagination to do it. I remember watching that on one of the late 80's episodes that was never on Unpaved.
Watch out! I'm getting ready to trade the copy of #162 and two TEC's with grobmeck so I can get #406 and #2558, but...#406 has featured the debut of one of the unusual muppets I've seen in early november of 2002. It was Sam the Robot! And, beware on #2558, because there was one of the most scariest letter segments of all time, so cover your face with your pillow, so you won't see it...it was the live-action segment with the red-hot steel 'I'! It played scary trumpet-and-piano music in the background and I believe that the 'I' was going to come through the TV and would burn you...I'm dying to see it, but in my youth, it scared me so much.