Okay, with that off me chest, the rest of the show ROCKED!!! Amazing, beautiful arrangements that satisfied the jazz cat in me (and also honestly should justify a cover album of some kind. I mean, a guy can dream, right?). I could guess they consciously chose some songs that were more jazz-oriented over others, which may explain why they picked the rather Dixieland-sounding "It's a Circle." Oscar and the Count's signature songs were notably absent, and a Cab Calloway-esque version of "The Song of the Count" would've been nice.
When I heard that a young, new performer would be taking over Hoots the Owl, something about it felt right to me; as when Hoots was first introduced, Kevin Clash was the young, new Muppeteer on the block, so the casting felt like a good way of starting anew. It was great to see and hear Hoots again, and interacting live with Elmo at that without the need for predubbing. Chris Hayes sounded recognizably like Hoots, and did a terrific job legitimately singing in that rough, gravelly voice. (Great right-handing for Ernie, too.)
Also, seeing all three shows livestreamed is as great an excuse as any to see live, raw puppetry at it's finest, warts and all. "I Don't Want to Live on the Moon" (which, again, had a fantastic, almost mysterious, jazz arrangement) had the gravy on top, re-enacting the bunraku puppetry from the original of Ernie dancing on the moon. It's something that may not have been necessary, but you're glad that they went to the effort of doing it.