-All the songs I kind of expected to hear, but "It's a Circle" threw me for a loop (no pun intended).
Yes, when I read the playbill before the show yesterday this early 2000's song was quite a surprise. There were many others that probably would've worked better. The performance was great, it just isn't one of Sesame's top "50 year" songs. There are numerous Ernie and Bert numbers that would've been a better choice.
I've got to say, Peter Linz did a fantastic job as Ernie. He covered three Jim Henson songs ("Rubber Duckie", "I Don't Want to Live on the Moon" and "Put Down the Duckie") and one Steve Whitmire song ("It's a Circle"). All were great. You know a performer has become a character when you no longer critique the performance and just enjoy it as the character (Ernie in this case).
As far as the rest of the show, here are some of my thoughts.
I was most surprised that "I Love Trash" wasn't featured. It would've been a great jazz arrangement.
"Mahna Mahna" after the intermission was an unexpected treat as it wasn't in the playbill. How great would it have been to have the Sesame Street Muppets sing this song again. The last time they covered it was back on "Play With Me Sesame". That was a missed opportunity.
"Pinball Number Count" seemed a little off. It's likely due to the Count and the cows both singing at the same time. It would've been nice if they alternated lines. Have the Count count solo and the cows sing backup. The vocals needed more room to breath.
I loved Grover roaming throughout the theater and up the balcony stairs. It was a subtle throwback to "Climbing Nine Stairs" from the "Numbers" album.
It was fantastic to see all the performers in full view on-stage during "Sing". This was very reminiscent of "The Mupet Show: Sex and Violence" closing credits.
An encore of "What the Name of that Song?" might have been a nice touch. Or even if an encore wasn't doable, have the band play the fan favorite "Funky Chimes" funding credit music after the characters leave the stage. That would've been incredible.
David Rudman, Marty Robinson and Stephanie D'Abruzzo were all missed.
These minor quibbles aside, the show was fantastic and it was a real treat to hear all these beloved Sesame Street tunes covered. I liked that the event was two weeks before the big anniversary and not in February. It's a really nice build-up to the 50th anniversary. This great event deserves a CD release featuring the best of the three performances.
All of these songs will be on Muppet Central Radio in the near future.