Why I Haven't Posted Anything in Ages: The Second Tale
You will notice that the question was not whether there would even be a next story.
When TogetherAgain started writing that first story, she hadn't given much thought to whether or not there would be a second one, but she mostly figured that there wouldn't be. She was just giving this a shot, after all, and it wasn't as if she felt very confident with her Muppet knowledge... but allow me to give you a little bit of background on TogetherAgain.
She decided when she was about six years old that she wanted to be an author when she grew up. (Note: Author, not writer, because she couldn't pronounce the letter R, so when she tried to say "writer," no one knew what she was talking about.) She was in sixth grade when she started doubting that decision because people were telling her all of the other things she should do or would be good at. A teacher! An architect! A psychiatrist! An accountant! And then, starting in seventh grade, English class started getting less and less fun... Did she really want to write?
Another thing you should know is that TogetherAgain was used to being smart, but she wasn't used to her brains getting her very far. Being smart meant the kids in Hebrew school didn't like her. It meant getting dirty looks for getting an A on the test she hadn't studied for. It meant getting dirty looks when she was right, slacked jaws when she didn't have an answer, and jeers when she was wrong, and let's not get into the look on her mother's face when her grades faltered. In short, being smart was a real drag.
Then one day, TogetherAgain found herself sitting in front of her computer screen, staring at a comment on her first Muppet fan fiction.
One of her readers had called her a genius.
He was not just any reader, either. He was Beauregard, a well-established, well-respected member and writer of an impressive fan fiction tale. Beauregard had been one of the members who had made TogetherAgain want to join Muppet Central. Beauregard had been one of the writers who had made TogetherAgain want to write. Now Beauregard was telling her that she was a genius... and he meant it, with respect, not resentment.
TogetherAgain spent a lot of time staring at that comment.
This... This was... new. ...And... though she doubted the accuracy of that word, as applied to her... This... felt good. And writing was, well... fun, and nothing at all like those miserable English classes. So by the time TogetherAgain finished her first story, she never even thought to question whether or not she would write a second.
What the story would be, however, was an entirely different matter.
While visiting her grandfather in the hospital, (which was not in itself unusual, considering that doctors had never expected him to live to adulthood and he was, by then, over ninety years of age,) TogetherAgain took out a notebook and started to think. Hm... She was quite fond of Rowlf the Dog. Maybe she could write a story with a little more focus on him? ...She was sitting in a hospital. Maybe that was where the story would start. But why would Rowlf be in the hospital? ...Well, maybe Gonzo had been firing some sort of cheese out of canons to the tune of... something... and one of the canons had misfired and somehow smothered Rowlf with cheese, and...
She made three or four attempts at starting that story, which persistently either refused to be written or kept going in the entirely wrong direction. A few scratched-out pages later, she started a different story, this one featuring another favorite character, Robin the Frog.
TogetherAgain entitled this second story "Chasing Robin," and she challenged herself to write more of the characters with whom she was not as comfortable: Clifford, Pepe, Johnny Fiama, Sal, Sweetums... For the most part, she found that they were easier (and more enjoyable) to write than she had expected, and in the meantime, all of her readers were still enjoying and praising each chapter. She felt herself falling into something of a rhythm with her writing, going outside to write in her notebook and then coming inside to type it up and post it and read, comment on, and nag for more of other stories.
The second story was done within a month, but TogetherAgain still had plenty of empty, nothing-better-to-do summer vacation ahead. It was only natural to start on a third story... if she could only think of one. But in the meantime, the commentary, deleted scenes, and making-of "extras" she had posted for the first story had been a great success, and had even been emulated by other writers on Muppet Central. Naturally, TogetherAgain tried her hand at commentary once again.
This time, however, posts replying to the commentary dwindled almost instantly. After several chapters in a row received absolutely no response from the readers, TogetherAgain stopped and left the commentary tradition to another writer known as theprawncracker, who really was much better (and funnier) at it anyway.
In the meantime, it was time for a third story, this one about... um...
This one about...
...This one... would be about... something. ...Eventually.