snichols1973
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2012
- Messages
- 958
- Reaction score
- 622
By the time of Archie Bunker's Place, the spin-off/continuation of the franchise, Arch still had a number of rough edges, many of which smoothed out with the passing of Edith's character, and Stephanie, his Jewish niece, living in the home. One of the notable episodes of ABP is when he ultimately decides to resign from the lodge when one of his fellow members starts insulting Mrs. Canby, his African-American housekeeper with racial insults, and he punches his lodge brother in the grocery store for the slurs made at her expense.One of my favorite sitcoms ever (and one of the best ever on tv) is "All in the Family".
When I was younger, I thought Archie Bunker was just a loud, ignorant racist pig. Just like my dad.
I thought Mike Stivic, the hippie liberal that I identified a lot with, that's how I was going to end up like. But things change.
In the beginning, much of the humor came from the tensions between conservative Archie and the liberal Meathead. But as the series progressed (and as I got older) I began to see Archie wasn't always wrong, and Mike wasn't always right.
Archie (when the series started, the character was 49, like me now) was a white, conservative, blue collar working stiff, stuck in a soon-to-be-outdated-job, unable to keep up with all the world changing around him. But he had a solid marriage to Edith the Dingbat, and strong Christian ties underneath his bigotry.
Mike Stivic was the polar opposite of Archie. Liberal, left-wing, aetheist, but felt entitled to live for free under Archie's roof and criticize his "old-fashioned" beliefs. Mike was the poster boy for the 70's equivalent of "Black Lives Matter", going out of his way to be Lionel Jefferson's best friend, and furthering the cause for Black people. But for all his self-righteousness, Mike was every bit as stubborn, cheauvinistic, and narrow-minded as he accused Archie of being.
I didn't think it was possible, but I can identify more with Archie now than I ever can with Mike. And that's not a bad thing.
Thank you Norman Lear, and your writers, for making the characters so deep over the course of nine seasons, as opposed to shallow stereotypes.
Some of the topical humor may have not aged well, but "All in the Family" can still strike a chord today.
On another occasion, Archie is faced with a difficult decision, and he ultimately volunteers to take a shift in watching over the synagogue, taking a step in the right direction to combat Anti-Semitic vandalism for the sake of Murray, his Jewish co-owner of the bar, and Stephanie, his niece...
Another touching moment in ABP is an early episode involving Edith and Stephanie preparing a Shabbat dinner, with Murray's mother and aunt coming over as guests, and Archie's awkwardness at participating in such an occasion...
Throughout the years, I've noticed that Edith usually seems to be the only sane person in the family sometimes, serving as the voice of reason that somehow manages to keep the peace, despite Archie calling her a "dingbat" and often telling her to "stifle it"...