They seem to have realized they made a mistake after the other two, so now they're making the film that they had originally promised.
Not exactly, but close enough.
What really happened is Paramount, by way of Nickelodeon Pictures originally had the license to make a trilogy of Smurf films set in the Medieval setting of the original comics. John Lithgow was set up to play Gargamel, and I can't remember if it was also meant to be a hybrid film, but they used the actual Smurf designs as the CGI models. Then somehow Nickelodeon decided it didn't
want to make these movies, and I can't remember if the sale of TMNT to them that could have been a factor (though I swear it was for the reason we didn't see that Mighty mouse film yet). But for whatever reason the rights reverted to Sony.
To which Sony had two concepts for the movie. The one we got, but also a horrible one that would have actually been far worse. In this version, the Smurfs were toys cried to life by some unpopular little girl who wanted friends. In other words,
that kind of movie, and the disgusting, freakish kid that didn't have any friends would have been played by the obvious "could win a children's beauty pageant" child actress. For better or worse, they went with the old He-Man/Fat Albert/those Mega Man OVA's "came in to the real world" plotline...which, unlike Master of the Universe they had the technology and budget to have them in their own time.
But anyway, the first movie was somehow an unexpected sleeper hit, making its money with weekday matinees to keep the little booger eaters out of the house. But the problem is, the second one had one striking disadvantage. Unlike Smurfs 1, Smurfs 2 opened around the time 3 other kid's films opened. Planes being one of them, taking the sleeper hit spot instead, causing the second Smurfs to be unsuccessful even though it was a better film. Sad thing is, they had something
great with "Smurfs Christmas Carol" and "Legend of Smurfy Hollow." I'm actually kinda sad to see the reboot change the voice cast. Hank Azaria's Gargamel was actually
worth watching the films for.
But I understand trying to do what they
should have in the first place. Much like Spider-Man, they screwed up and want to keep the franchise. Unlike Spider-Man, they didn't beef the second of the reboot so badly they just said "Hey! Marvel Disney! You can totally use him if you can make our Spidey movies not suck."