This cast has no excuse. None.
I think the argument basically hinges around this: Either these are the same ol' guys we've loved, or they are strangers--to us and to themselves.
The fact that they don't seem to know how to react to each other argues strongly for the second.
I will agree you a bit on this, only in that - at least for these performers - they've gotten two movies under their belts, but with that said, movies take longer to film than a TV show and in some respects, have a little more leeway than a show does.
There's also more Executive Meddling done in TV shows than anything else.
Again, I'm not saying that the performers don't know who their characters are or what their backstory is; it's most likely not the performers, but the network. FOX is a great example, in that The Simpsons is still going, despite the fact that many of the voice actors have been trying to get out of their contracts and as someone mentioned earlier, Seth McFarlane has been trying to end some of his shows, but is being prevented because, let's face it, FOX needs all the help it can get.
Kermit going after Fozzie to bring him home was the closest thing we've seen to "normal" interaction. There was a warmth there that felt familiar. On the other hand, the thought of seeing our guys stumbling around drunk-singing doesn't sound very appealing--especially if they dump Kermit to do it.
I know many of the folks in this discussion don't ever venture over into the fanfic board, Webmistress Gina, but I know you do. I know you know that, in my stories, I have allowed these characters to be very adult and very complex and sometimes very flawed, but I've never treated them disrespectfully. I feel as though the scenarios the writers have put them in in this show are designed to make them look foolish and jerky.
And I really hate the idea that the "pinnacle" of entertainment people are comparing "the muppets" to is no highter than The Simpsons or Family Guy, both of whom RELY on offensive humor and smuttiness, even when they are trying to make a point.
You know I loves your stuff - it was the reason I joined - and you know that yes, if I had to choose to see something come alive from the fic board, I would honestly choose it over our current show, BUT, as I've mentioned to my roommate many times, Hollywood isn't catering to our age group.
A couple of people have mentioned it already - the Hollywood machine is going where the money is and that's usually, always with kids. Parents pretty much bend to the will of their kids now and they're gonna be the ones spending money and buying them the tie-in toys and merchandise. And, come on let's be honest, the Muppets right now - with Disney - is a part of the cash cow machine.
It's the reason Disney is redoing just about every single one of their animated hits as live action versions and why they're building a Star Wars land. It's also the reason Frozen managed to bump off Muppets 3D from both Disneyland and Disney World (I was not happy in learning that when I went to DL last month, cause that was on my ride/attraction rotation) and why there's a Frozen 2 in the works.
Again, I blame parents because if it wasn't for you and your kid, we wouldn't be getting a live version of the Jungle Book. There doesn't need to be another live version of the Jungle Book; nor does there need to be a live version of Beauty and the Beast or Cinderella or 101 Dalmatians or the Lion King or any movie that's in the Disney catalogue. Children will watch what you tell them (hence why you're the parent).
Anyway, I like the new show, but I'm not comparing it to TMS cause it's not and I know it's not. Just like the new movies aren't TMM, GMC, or MTM; I'm just happy that the Muppets are back on TV and in the movies. It's only been 3 episodes and it's not as terrible as I was afraid it would be. Again, if the whole group comes together at the end of this week's episode in true Muppet form and true, "Kermit, we totally screwed up and we're gonna make it up to you a thousand percent", then we might be heading somewhere.