For no reason at all I have painstakingly gone through all of The Great Muppet Survey entries to tally up which characters have been referred to as the favorites of each contributor. I am counting instances where the survey takers cheated a little by doing ties or including more than three characters from each production without resorting to ties.
From The Muppets:
Gonzo - 24
Kermit - 21
Rowlf - 12
Fozzie - 11
Miss Piggy - 6
Pepe - 6
Scooter - 5
Floyd - 5
Beaker - 4
Walter - 4
Robin - 3
Rizzo - 2
Uncle Deadley - 2
Dr. Teeth - 2
Lew Zealand - 2
The Swedish Chef - 2
Zoot - 1
Lips - 1
Johnny Fiama - 1
Statler and Waldorf - 1
Sam the Eagle - 1
Sweetums - 1
Digit - 1
Penguins - 1
Bobo - 1
Janice - 1
Electric Mayhem - 1
There was one who included the whole Electric Mayhem, so I'm not sure whether I should add one to each member (which would give Floyd a 6, Dr. Teeth a 3, Janice, Zoot, and Lips each a 2, and Animal a 1). Unless I missed something, I'm surprised that Animal didn't get listed as a top 3 favorite for even just one fan. With all the Animal and Kermit merchandise out there while the others get significantly less, we should send this to Disney, and let them know that, as far as survey-takes go, there are more fans who listed Gonzo as one of their three favorites than Kermit. I'm also surprised by the low scores of Beaker and Swedish Chef, and it is a shame Bunsen wasn't included (nobody even included a tie between Bunsen and Beaker, like many did for Ernie and Bert). Though when I took mine, I did consider listing Bunsen and Beaker among my three favorites.
From Sesame Street:
Grover - 23
Big Bird - 18
Ernie - 17
Bert - 17
Cookie Monster - 14
Oscar - 11
The Count - 7
Mr. Snuffleupagus - 3
Telly - 3
Slimey - 2
Elmo - 2
Don Music - 2
Guy Smiley - 1
Barkley - 1
Abby Cadabby - 1
Roosevelt Franklin - 1
I wasn't surprised that Grover got the most picks. Actually even before I decided to keep track of how many times a character was picked I could tell Grover was in first place. Heck, with all three franchises I could tell who the top two choices were (and in all three cases I picked one of the top two - for Muppets I picked Kermit, Sesame Grover, and Fraggle Boober). I sort of regret not including Herry (I thought about him.... and a lot of others), seeing as nobody else did.
From Fraggle Rock:
Wembly - 24
Boober - 16
Cantus - 10
Sprocket - 9
Traveling Matt - 9
Red - 9
Gobo - 8
Mokey - 6
Junior Gorg - 5
Trash Heap - 4
Sidebottom - 3
Cotterpin - 2
Convincing John - 2
Doc - 1
World's Oldest Fraggle - 1
Lanford - 1
There was only one entry from somebody who didn't pick any Fraggle Rock characters due to not seeing much of the show. Though there were a few others who hadn't seen much of the show but did pick anyway (there's also some who aren't too familiar with Sesame Street but did make choices anyway).
And if Grover had only gotten one more pick (unless I miscounted or missed an entry) then the top picks for all three franchises would have been 24.