Scarecroe: Yes, you're right, it's "Two Lost Souls." I'm not doing too well with song titles, am I? I'll have to think about that while I conduct my four-finger orchestra.
I like the suggestion that they just re-issue the movie soundtracks. However, any Muppet compilation may have to have a few songs on it that even the casual Muppet fan knows, like "Movin' Right Along."
Other songs I'd like to see on a CD (some have already been mentioned):
"Comedy Tonight" with assorted Muppets
"Mr. Bassman" with Scooter and Floyd
"Lullaby of Broadway" with assorted Muppets
"Another Opening of Another Show" with Fozzie, Link, Rizzo, etc. (Thanks for reminding me of the title, Cantus!)
"More, More, More" from Muppets at Walt Disney World
"Octopus' Garden" with Kermit, Piggy and Robin
An "At the Dance" sketch
There's a song on the Bob Hope episode after the commercial break with the whole cast sitting around a fireplace. Does anyone know the name of that one?