I went to both Puppet Up! shows last night at the Hollywood Improv. Combining a "Whose Line Is It Anyway" style with Muppet-style puppets (there were no familiar characters, which I think is a good choice), in a live adult comedy venue, Puppet Up! is an excellent experiment for the Henson company. This is the most fun I've had seeing live puppets in a long time!
Some highlights included a director making a movie about a little girl, an aardvark and some other creature (can't remember) in a plastic surgery office. The director puppet kept interrupting. "CUT CUT! Do it faster..." (The performers do the whole scene again, hyper-speed). "CUT! Audience, give me an emotion..." Someone shouted "LUST" and the "movie" detiorated into an absurd porn scene with appropriate music. Then the director asked for a film-style. "Film Noir", shouted an audience member. The music shifted to a light jazzy ambience, and the aardvark's voice became voice-over, and everyone's acting became stoic and, well, Film Noir-like. Later in another sketch, a valley-girlish woman was trying to square-dance with three aliens. Oh yes, and an extended sketch about a mouse and a beaver with a nose-hair issue threatening to tear their love apart. Absolutely hiliarous. There were some brilliant characters that popped up, like the dim-witted super-hero at a homeless shelter (Tyler Bunch), the hot dog that sounded like Fat Albert (couldn't see who that was), and pretty much all girl characters played by Julienne Buescher, who was unbelievably good! Everyone was. Patrick (the MC and Improv instructor from the Groundlings) put "the grinder" as they called it on Victor and Drew, by making them go backwards and forwards, have their sentences start in alphabetical order, or rhyme. Insane!
Of course, if you're squeemish or like your Muppets to be innocent, this event would not have been for you. That'd be true for any adult improv venue, really. From talking to people who worked with Jim, I cannot say I agree that he believed everything should be wholesome and child-proof. Go to the Museum of TV & Radio and watch Kermit's performance on old "Sonny & Cher" shows. Kermit hits on her with the line "So, uh... you wanna... fool around?" Granted, it's not South Park or even Avenue Q, but hardly Sesame Street.
That caveat aside, if you think you might like it, DEFINITELY go see it if you can. They videotaped both shows last night, and some of the cast is going to Scotland to perform at a festival there. I suspect eventually, this sort of thing could end up on TV (cable, I hope) or in more live venues.