unclematt said:
I know Eric would still work but I thinkthat it is important that these are now Eric's characters. I dont think the Muppets should keep being passed back and forth.
I agree. Once there's that transition to a new performer it takes some getting used to but eventually the audience is going to recognize the new performer's version of the character. It would be confusing to the audience if the performer keeps switching. Think of how we feel now when we watch the early episodes of TMS and Piggy's voice switches from Frank to Richard
within the same episode at times. It's very odd and it pulls you out of it for a second. I find it odd that Frank sometimes comes back to Sesame Street even though Eric's taken over his roles.
I also think that Eric is doing a really great job. In the few things he's done since he took over for Piggy and Fozzie in 2001 his improvement has been vast. His Piggy is terrific and his Fozzie is stronger with every appearance. He did an
excellent job on Red & Green Christmas. Of all the recent Muppet replacements, Eric has the fullest of my confidences (...is that grammatically correct?). I'm much more concerned about Jerry Nelson's replacements. I like John Kennedy but Jerry has such a distinctive voice that I don't think anyone will be able to fully replace him. John's song on Red & Green Christmas was good, but it wasn't Floyd for me. (And this might be anarchy on this Barretta-lovin' forum, but Bill Barretta isn't Dr. Teeth or Rowlf to me either.) But Eric? I definitely heart him.