For what it is worth, I'll start by sharing this so you know where I come from: I work for AOL as a blogger for the website Cinematical. Cine is a member of Weblogs, Inc, one of the absolute largest blog companies existing. We pull in a good amount of traffic. I'm the regular geek-beat writer, doing anywhere from 50-100 posts per month. I've written about my Muppet love on more than one occasion via my regular weekly column, "The Geek Beat," and my shorter posts.
Personally, I don't understand why we need to have company members involved to enjoy ourselves. Yes, it would be crazy-fantastic if we could have another MuppetFest with major headliner guests.
If we can't do that, why not just all get together to celebrate our love for all things Muppet? My friends and I regularly get together for Muppet viewings (this weekend is Christmas With the Muppets, watching Christmas Eve on Sesame Street, AVMMCM, MCC, MFC, and A Christmas Toy) and have a grand time. Why not just do that, but bigger?
Heck with another Fest if we can't pull it off. Why not just rent out a place and all get together to watch a ton of Muppet stuff with people who love and appreciate it? Yeah, it won't be as grand as MuppetFest, but it is much more doable, and thorougly fun. Think of it as a MuppetCentral Meet 'n Greet Party.
If it happens on any sort of large scale, we can get minor media coverage. Who knows, it might catch Disney's eye and let them know we still exist and care. If it gets any traction at all, Cinematical may let me cover it, which would at least give the thing exposure through AOL.