BEAR
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- May 21, 2005
- Messages
- 7,368
- Reaction score
- 35
Rattus P Rattus said:is there a way to tell the differences of Frank Oz' Cookie Monster, Grover and Bert from David Rudman's Cookie Monster and Eric Jacobson's Grover and Bert?
I am glad you asked this, Rattus, because it is something that I have been studying lately. As far as Eric Jacobson's performances of Grover and Bert, i am still trying to figure it out. As of now, it just seems like a difference in vocal pitch to Frank. As far as the characterizations are concerned, so far I think that Jacobson has stayed true to the original concepts of the personalities. David Rudman's Cookie Monster differs quite a bit from Frank's and it is not difficult to notice. Again, there is a pitch thing going on. And to be honest, it just sounds like a poor attempt at imitating the character. David's Cookie seems dumber. Cookie Monster was not always the brightest monster on the street but he wasn't stupid either and David's Cookie acts like a dumb caveman. Basically, I feel like there is no depth in the character anymore. Like it is just something Rudman has to do.
Hope this helps somewhat. That is all I have to say for now until I can review the performances again. I will get back on this soon.