Again, I have to say, they made background animals from the Circle of Life number as large, unsellable plush. I don't care how popular Lion King is... no one wants characters that didn't have a line. Scar, Mufasa, both age variants of Simba and Nala, Timon, Pumbaa, the hyenas, Zazu, even Simbas Mom... heck, even the wildebeests. But who wants a generic Zebra?\
Muppets however, you'd have to go all the way in the back and reach for an obscure one for it to sell like a lead balloon. I'm sure fans would clamor for a Crazy Harry, a Newsman, or even Lew Zealand plush. The fact we don't have Rowlf or Chef yet is disappointing, though again... who would ever think we'd have a plush of Pepe? Something the fanbase was screaming for the past 10 years. The initial notes of commitment are there, but it seems this will all depend on the movie's success, if not the success of the Muppet toys. And they are moving.
I hope this IS one of those times they grossly underestimate these things and wait until the DVD comes out, like they did with Bolt.