I actually really like the dummy one. Somehow the "No one at all" bit almost makes me hear Homer's voice in my head saying "OH! Stupid sexy dummy."I should also point out that those Progressive Flo commercials are getting creepier and creepier. That one where one of the two guys has a dummy is pretty good, but these latest ones where Flo plays multiple roles and plays her own family members are just unnerving.
But those ones where Flo pulls an Eddie Murphy in Nutty Professor... I'll admit they are well done, and the actress shouldn't be pidgeonholed into being that mascot (she was in Mad Men and 2 Broke Girls and was almost unrecognizable and good in both roles)... but the subtext is depressing as heck. The unfavorite bit should be funny, but comes off extremely depressing with the fridge horror that Flo's perky attitude comes off as a mask, hiding a bitter pain of rejection from her own family, even though she seems to actually be the successful one in a group of angry losers. Considering that in other commercials she really loves her job with an almost psychotic gusto, this is a very dark message they're bringing. All played for Laughs, too. Smart move, guys. Now all I can do is picture a drunk Flo crying herself to sleep every night.
But yeah. The ones where everyone turns into Flo and the one where the woman has a very disturbing obsession with Flo and making a hand puppet out of her... those are scary.