Originally posted by The Big Don
Hey Ken. I posted something about this over at SCS. Anyways, Why arent you guys going off in to different sets. I mean, you have the rights to the 6 movies. So why not just keep the Muppet Show line the same, and instead of inserting Sam Arroel in Series 4, hvae Treausre Island 1 or something.
My other questions:
What are the odds of getting all/some of the Pirate Muppets from Muppet Treasure Island and Gonzo from Muppet Christmas Carol.
Is there a possibility of movie only lines. Because I think that would be better. This line would last alot longer that way and be great.
I answered this there but only briefly. I disagree about doing movie specific lines. It creates a problem with retail buyer perception. You have a successful Muppet line, then come out with a separate line, for arguments sake, called Muppets From Space. The buyer now has two different lines to choose from and has the ability to say "You know, Muppets From Space didn't do so well at the box office, I think I'll pass on that." In an all-inclusive line like Muppets, with different characters from different sources like Star Wars Power of the Force and Saga, you keep the one successful line. with the important BRAND identity, with multiple character sources and the only real measure of success the retailer has is the line that came before it.
I believe this hurt the Celebrity line from Simpson's for that reason AND because some collectors, who are in lots of ways completists, said "Hey it ain't really my Simpson's line so I don't really need those to complete my collection." That was my reaction to it, and I am only getting the celebs because I got them in a trade.
The Star Wars precedent is a good one. If they put out more figures from, say, Episode One in an Episode One branded line, I guarantee you it would not get into retail, because of the problems Episode One branded product had. But they can sneak a Maul or Qui-Gon into Saga, extend their character base and give fans a chance at some figs they might want, and avoid that automatic association with a bunch of clearanced product.
As for the other stuff, yeah there is a chance we would ultimately do all the versions from MTI or any other source material...that depends, entirely, on you, other collectors and the people who frequent this board. If no one buys the line, then probably not. If people keep buying and collecting it, then yeah we would take it as far as we could.