American Idol

[dmx10101]

Jasmine is, uh, pretty attractive, and I guess she sings good too.

 

[AndyWan Kenobi]

I'm a wee bit disappointed that Scooter Girl is not coming back for the wildcard show, but I think they have a really good lineup for next week.

 

[Don'tLiveonMoon]

I don't know what I was thinking. I was positive there was another Jasmine in the top 12, but I guess I had her mixed up with Camille.
Erin

 

[ceecee]

Sooooooo?

What does everyone think about the final 12?

I knew George Huff would make it. He's so cool!

I'm way excited about Jon Peter! I couldn't help grinning for him when he was singing last night.

 

[GonzoGirl]

I'm excited for Jon Peter, too, I think he's been doing really well, despite what Simon says. I was disappointed that Micheal Metger didn't make it-he really has alot of talent, I just think he lacks enough confidence in himself...but I think he'll be back next year, and able to kick some butt.
I think the only person in the final 12 I really don't like is the one girl Paula chose, Leia Labelle. She can sing, sorta, there is just something about her I really can't stand.

 

[AndyWan Kenobi]

I was pretty pleased with the choices, even though I think Suzy Vulaca did really well. I'm so happy about George Huff--and to think, he was brought in as a replacement! I'm really happy he's in the top 12, though--he's got a good voice and a delightful personality.

I'm really happy about Jon Peter Lewis as well--I've always really liked him. He's got this great dorky charm that I really dig. His dancing absolutely cracked me up, which is a good thing--I think he had, overall, the most entertaining performance of the night.

 

[Don'tLiveonMoon]

Yeah, I kinda thought Suzy might go through on one of the judges' picks, but I'm not surprised they picked Leah because they reallly seem to have been in her corner all this time. I'm very happy about George and Jon Peter, and I like Jennifer too. Wasn't EJay a replacement, too, in the first season? Seems to me he wasn't in the top 30 originally but replaced someone who had claimed to be younger than he really was. It's interesting when it works out like that. Kinda makes you wonder who else slipped through the cracks...

About Matthew coming back, I was wondering if you're allowed to audition again once you hit the top 32. It kinda seems like they wouldn't let you do that because they wouldn't want the same people showing up again and again. I don't think I've seen any top 30 or 32 people back in later rounds.
Erin

 

[AndyWan Kenobi]

About Matthew coming back, I was wondering if you're allowed to audition again once you hit the top 32. It kinda seems like they wouldn't let you do that because they wouldn't want the same people showing up again and again. I don't think I've seen any top 30 or 32 people back in later rounds.
Erin

I think they actually prohibit people from reauditioning once they reach the top 32. That's sad, because that means that Lisa won't be back...

 

[Don'tLiveonMoon]

I wonder, though, if a lot of the people who made it that far have more opportunities back home because of the exposure the got.
Erin

 

[Boober_Gorg]

I think they actually prohibit people from reauditioning once they reach the top 32. That's sad, because that means that Lisa won't be back...

Lisa got screwed over on the Wild Card show. They didn't even give her a reason why they booted her off.

My mom's never watching the show again, and neither am I.