Well I tried to post this to you, Scott, but that does not seem to be an option on the new board, so I hope you will scan and read. I have decided to take Emileigh to Sesame Place in May this year, and then save the return ticket (which is free with full purchase price) for a trip in October for The Count's Boo-Spectacular weekend (or named something like that).
Thing is, in the summer, SP is just crammed with people who are mostly there to ride the water rides. Since we live at the beach, the water rides are not that important to us... we are there to see MUPPETS darn it, not to swim with the great unwashed of Philadelphia (no offense to those from Philly, but if you have been to SP in August, I think you know what I mean!). If you go on the "off season", you get a better view for the shows and the characters on the Street. (I always wondered why they felt they needed the draw of the water rides anyway. Why not just expand on the Muppet shows and theme rides?)
Have you ever been to SP? It is kinda a drive for you I think, but could be combined with other local attractions like the beach, or museums and zoo in Philly!