I think Piggy would probably end up taking top honors for best and worst hairstyles!
But yeah, Janice's side ponytail came close to worst - i mean what were they thinking and why did it take ages to change it back? The band got a little bit of a makeover mid-80's and i guess they had a hard time making Janice look 80's while still maintaining her 60's essence so they just said "hey let's give her a ponytail - on the side - it's the 80s and silly hair is the thing right?"
Amen! Glad to see I'm not the only one to pick up on that. I'm a bit iffy and overly-cautious when it comes with clashing different decade styles.
I agree with you about Piggy, too. In the past she's had the best AND the worst hairstyle(s) out of the Muppets, lol! Although it really comes down to the era, really. I mean, she's gonna have a perm in TMTM, because it was made in the 80s- it was fashionable, sooo... she has an excuse.
I didn't like her as a brunette that much, though. She suits blonde hair, though she didn't look half bad with black hair in MWoZ, it was cute in a Bettie Page sorta way.