Yeah I vote for the "Beat the Time" one. When Guy Smiley says to Cookie Monster, "On your mark, get set, Go! " and the clock starts ticking, Cookie monster just stands there and says nonchalantly, "When do me start?". It is so hilarious when Guy screams, "You start now!!! GO GO GO GO!!!" and Cookie goes, " OH OH!! "
The bakery shop one was probably my next fave Guy Smiley moment. Loved when Cookie said, "Wait, me know what rhymes with buy and is in bakery and is delicious" and Guy turns puzzled to the audience and says, "What's he talking about?' Then of course Cookie chasing Guy and trying to munch on him was a riot.
An extremely funny moment to me involved a News Flash skit where it was Prince Charming instead of Guy Smiley ( but similar look and voice). He was going to rescue Rapunzel and Kermit asks him, "Would you mind sharing with us how you plan to rescue her?" He says, "Yes"(sounded kind of like Yesh!).
Kermit says, "Oh you DO mind?" He says, "Yes." Kermit says, " So you're not going to tell us?" And he says, "No way!"