The Halloween online store item I ordered (thanks for those who informed me of it) just arrived and has been painted. The paint is a little tacky and sticky on the black rubber. The velcro attachment doesn't look all that great so I chopped off the ends and created a hole to poke one of the spikes through to make it look more latch-like in the back. No, this isn't as signature-looking as I'd like, but it will work nicely the paint ever completely dries! I used one of those soft metalic silver paint markers. The color matches and fills the area great, but it still seems gummy. I might have to coat it in something.
another completely unretouched Animal photo set:
http://www.wijitworld.com/stock_images/animal_collar.jpg
He just keeps looking better!