Thanks
Yea, more or less. I also thought of Piggy being Major Hollihan. Rizzo would just be a rat that hangs around. I keep entertaining the idea that Sam goud be Major Potter. Actually, Radar's a puzzle to me because I keep thinking that Robin could also be Radar along with Scooter. Scooter certainly would be a good choice as he's kinda the organizer of the grou like Radar is, but Robin's the kid of the group which is how Radar is seen at times. But the more I think about it I think you're right with Scooter.
I was thinking Sam as Potter too, particularly Potter when he first came the 4077th. But then again, part of me is thinking he might make a good Frank in a way. Father Mulcahy was at the piano a few times, I dunno, maybe Rowlf could play him haha.
And as for Scooter or Robin as Radar. I think you have a point for Robin too. But thinking about Radar's journey on the show - he started off as a kid and left the camp a young man. Much like Scooter even when Richard was performing him. I remember one fan here noting Scooter's voice change over the years with Richard, even saying "It's almost as if Richard had been aging him". That's always stuck with me for some reason and I've noticed Scooter's voice change even during his time of The Muppet Show
Oh, and You might be an obsessed Muppet fan if... you bought a
Best of The Muppet Show Volume 1 VHS at a Charity shop (which I did today)