Super Scooter said:
The voice is only a small percentage of the performance of a character.
It depends what your taste is. I prefer a dead on voice first and actual performance later. That's why I prefer Steve as Statler because the voice is right on. Of course it helps that the performer stay in character and perform the character well.
Of all the replacements and alternatives I like Piggy, Fozzie, Animal, Sam, Rowlf, Scooter, and Statler (Steve's not Jerry's. Sorry) the best. Wow, I just realized that almost all of the characters' perfromers have been replaced in some way.
OH! I forgot Beaker. Infact I didn't even know Beaker was performed by Richard and then Steve until I came to these boards. Before then I thought Scooter and Janice were gone because the person who performed them had quit. I know better now, but I was much happier before I knew better.