Hello, Manda...I'm a Fiery....BWHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!
I could see how that would scare you. I was 13 at the time, so it didn't bother me. I was 14 when JHH came out, so Digit didn't scare me either...but I can see how he would!
MuppetPro: I find it hilarious that you're talking about Statler being scary, and the eMuppecon is saying "boo"! He's supposed to be making fun of a bad performance, but it looks like he's saying "boo" like a ghost!
Randall: I think I vaguely recall what you're talking about. I'll try to remember to ask my friend, who's a SS expert. I agree that the Phantom of the Muppet Show (aka Uncle Deadly) was the creepiest, though I don't recall being scared by him either.
As for me: the scariest characters were always the most "realistic" ones. One example is the human-looking Muppets in the "Gambler" number of the Kenny Rogers episode (especially when the one DIES and his ghost starts dancing around!) There's also another number (the Cleo Laine episode, maybe?) where there were a couple of realistic human-looking Muppets in a field. One of them died, and the other one watched their spirit fly off, or something like that. Brrrr.
I don't remember seeing the "Lime in the Coconut" number in the Kenny Rogers episode when I was a kid, but if I had, that number would have scared me as well. The whole thing's so bizarre...and the witch doctor's eyes...
Come to think of it, I think I'm scared of it as an adult.