Excluding Sesame Street merchandise, here's what I'd like to see:
1. Muppet Movie soundtrack CD (re-release)
2. Muppet Show seasons 2-5 on DVD
3. "The Jim Henson Collection" DVD set--including Sam and Friends, Time Piece, early Muppet commercials like Wilkins/Won'tkins and the La Choy Dragon, and, if possible, the Rowlf segments from the Jimmy Dean Show
4. Fireys action figures with interchangeable heads, arms, and legs
5. Thog action figure
If you want me to stay somewhere near the realm of reality, I'd have to replace 4 and 5 with something else. The Jim Henson Hour sounds nice, though I don't know how that would work without the Storyteller segments (I just doubt they'd be included on competing DVDs).
And I have to admit I've been longing to see more of Little Muppet Monsters since those long-gone days of hearing that incredibly-catchy theme song on a couple of Saturday mornings. . . . After that, the show disappeared, and I kept waiting every Saturday for it to reappear, but it never did. . . .