To get off-topic, Nigel is one of the more interesting Muppet characters: you go from potentially being the host of TMS to being a really obscure background character; the fact he was also a Jim character adds fuel to the fire... give me that fanfic pls: Nigel with a switchblade behind his back approaching Kermit in a dark alley... they should've used him instead of Constantine.
Mr. Poodlepants! I thought he was THE most useless, unrememberable character in the whole Muppets franchise! What EXACTLY did he do or what was he used for?! He was more of a Disney character than Muppet. I liked everybody else!
Why don't we all list our own picks for top 5 best/worst Muppets now? I'll start:
5. Sam the Eagle
4. Waldo C. Graphic
5. Walter (I like him... but oh boy is he boring )