I don't really believe the original has aged well. Like, at all. The original was created in a pre-social media era of the internet, where congregating on forums such as this was far more common. With so much of the original built around the forum community and such, I don't know how a reboot, remake, next-gen spinoff, or what have you would even work.
Not to mention, since the original was MrsPepper's concept, I think it should be up to her whether this should happen, though I doubt she'd approve.