[Fade-in. Sir David Tushingham, Robin, and Waldo appear just outside a large apartment complex. It has a brick facade, multiple apartments with balconies overlooking a canal.]
Tushingham (looking around): What does this have to do with the secret of the Muppets?
Waldo (looks around): It’s an apartment now, but up until the year 2005, Jim Henson’s Creature Shop of London was where experimentation in puppetry happened.
Tushingham (sighs): But how are we going … no, wait … why would we go inside? I’m trying to search for truth, not rent a flat for a reasonable fee and pleasant scenery.
Waldo (rolling his eyes): C’mon … this is a mystery movie.
Robin (suddenly understands): And in mystery movies, there are always secret areas that hide treasure!
Waldo (grins, nodding): Exactly! *flies over to the lowest level and a light beams out of his eyes, scanning a section of the wall, revealing a hidden panel, which opens a camouflaged door* C’mon, everybody! *enters*
Robin and Tushingham (look at each other, shrug, and enter)
[The scene cuts to a dark interior. The only illumination comes from a central pedestal that shines a light on the Jim, Frank, and Jerry puppets, who sit on display on top of the pillar. The music is hushed. As they enter the room, they pass a panel that preserves their images in multiple segments of the panel, such as the special lights to be found in the apartment complex.]
Robin (approaches the puppet trio): I’ve seen them at the Theater … a long time ago.
Waldo (nods and approaches, his voice low and solemn): Jim, Frank, and Jerry … they are some of the original members of the Doll-Making Man Club.
Tushingham: You mean the humans they’re based on?
Waldo: Uh, yeah. That.
Robin (taps the pillar, looking up at the puppet trio): What happened? Why are they like that?
Waldo (flies in closer to inspect, shrugging): A puppet is more than just a hand in a glove. There has to be heart as well. When these three decided to retire, they joined the rest of them in perfect poses.
Robin and Tushingham: “The rest of them?”
Waldo (his tie swirling around, lights coming on all over the room, illuminating glass cases on the wall with lots of puppets based on humans, such as Paul Williams and Tim Curry and anyone else they happened to make Muppets out of, like Tom Cruise and Bernie Brillstein)
Robin: Wow ….
Waldo (voice-over as the camera pans around the room to offer closer shots of the Muppet humans): Humans put their hearts and souls into their creations. I’m sure Digit already told you, but the human tendency to destroy lots of life also makes them obsessed with avoiding it --.
Digit (suddenly appears with Vicki, whose arms are around him): Waldo! I think you’ve said quite enough!
Waldo (surprised): Digit? Vicki? What are you doing here? I thought you wanted them to know the secret of Muppet origins!
Digit: Not all of them!
Robin (approaching Digit): What does that mean? *nods to Waldo* How could anyone hate this particular revelation? I mean, we mean so much to humans that a part of their hearts go into us! We’re alive … as long as just one person believes in us!
Waldo (panicking): Digit, I’m sorry! What I meant to say was, humans try to create life!
Tushingham (shakes his head): No! That’s not what you said at all! You said “avoid”!
Digit (shaking his head): I can’t allow this continue any further! *music starts to get more frantic as he pulls some sort of remote control out of his pocket* If you’re desperate to expand your minds, I think I’ve got just the ticket! *points to the remote and inches toward them, making them all back up* This remote will zap you to the farthest reaches of the universe!
Robin and Vicki: But Digit!
Vicki (grabs Digit by the shoulder): Digit! This is wrong! *reaches for his off-button*
Digit (sweeps her away): I’m not glitching, Vicki! I am Digit! I am a cyborg! I’m not going to let David and --.
Tushingham (under his breath): Sir David.
Digit (continuing): -- Robin destroy my plans! *turns to the others* I’ve spent a very long time cooped up in that control room, watching the universe. I’ve learned lots of things.
Vicki (kicks Digit across the room with a loud kyah-like sound, shaking her head afterward): You’ve learned how to monologue ridiculously, I see. *giggles … in a very familiar way*
Robin (aghast): Vicki! He’s your boyfriend!
Waldo (slowly flies away, only to be stopped by Kermit, who is standing in the doorway)
Kermit (frowning): Waldo, what’s the matter with you? Why couldn’t you just be a part of the dream?
Robin (shocked): Uncle Kermit!
Tushingham (to the audience, holding up a pad and paper): Would any of you out there like a page? You’ll probably need this.
Waldo (glances nervously at the groaning form of Digit): This wasn’t supposed to happen! *flies away from Kermit and the others, who approach him, big sweat drops dripping from his small body* I met Digit when he was very young. He was just out of high school. All he wanted was some help. That’s it … I was only trying to help!
[Waldo seems oblivious as his top hat projects an image on the wall behind him. A teenage boy is in a hospital bed, wrapped in lots of bandages. In a parody of the scene where Dark Alessa peers into a hole in a curtain and the burned Alessa turns to darkness, the camera uses Waldo’s POV, flying lazily toward the curtain. Peeking around it, the bandaged Digit reaches out pleadingly, and the camera nods. Circuitry patterns spread across the curtain.]
Waldo (narrating the scene): There was an accident. Muppets live forever, he said. He had grown up watching them. His parents had watched them. If he couldn’t be turned into a Muppet, he’d die. I brought him to Honeydew, who at the time was applying for membership in NAST.
Vicki (horrified): You … you ….
Waldo (stops projecting and glares at Vicki): It’s when he met you that my plan started going downhill.
Robin (peering at Tushingham’s pad of paper and back at Waldo): You mean Digit isn’t the Monitor?
Waldo (laughs, shaking his head): Of course not! Digit is just my puppet! *starts to turn red* Do you really think that glitchy cyborg has the attention span to be a villain? No! All he cared about was living forever! *glares at Kermit* That house on that street you lived on … do you remember? I went there once. I wanted to be part of the dream. I was going to meet with you after my date. But you weren’t there!
Kermit (with just a hint of pleading): Waldo, quiet down. I hired you, didn’t I?
Waldo (nods exaggeratedly, sarcastically): Oh, yeah! You hired me for less than ten episodes and then I got shown just how valuable we technological entities really are!
Vicki: At least you helped Muppet Labs over at Disney’s Muppet Vision! I couldn’t get anywhere within a hundred miles of that theme park!
Waldo (shakes his head): I don’t care! The Doll-Making Man Club was designed to give life to inanimate objects! Why are CG characters and robots so unlovable? Why can’t we have any rights? Any fame?
Kermit (grunts with disapproval): Now, look here, Waldo – 3PO and R2 ….
Waldo (buzzing around the room): I don’t care! I don’t care if they were on the show! Just like the Vend-a-face and those wind-up Muppets and humans … they were all just one note token appearances to shut them up! You wanna drive down the fandom for the Muppets real quick? Suggest it be animated in the computer and see how fast they all run! Haven’t you ever read Frankenstein? Don’t make something if you don’t want to take care of it! *starts shooting lasers out of his eyes as the others scramble around the room, sparks and smoke everywhere*
Vicki (rolling on the floor to dodge the lasers)
Waldo (still ranting to no one in particular): Jar-Jar’s more hated than that fat, animatronic slug – that eats frogs! *gets blinded by a rubber mask shaped like Vicki’s face and stops* Huh? *is taken down by a blurry orange-skinned female figure*
Robin (gawking): You?
Tushingham (shaking his head as he looks at his pad): I’m thoroughly confused. *glances at the audience* Are any of you following all this?
[The camera pans around the room from Tushingham to reveal an adult Skeeter, dressed similarly to her comic book counterpart, crouched over the stunned form of Waldo.]
Kermit (nods, sighing with relief): Thanks, Skeeter.
Robin: Skeeter?
Skeeter (nodding, smiling): Scooter’s sister, remember? *holds out a hand* Good to see you again, Robin. You’ve grown a lot since I last saw you. *giggles* You didn’t even have legs yet. *stands up and holds the unconscious Waldo up to Kermit* Sorry, Boss.
Tushingham (sighs): So, Waldo was the evil Monitor all this time.
Kermit (shrugs): Well … no. He was actually the villain, but he’s not the Monitor.
Robin (frustrated): Well, who is the Monitor?
Skeeter (shrugging with a smirk): Isn’t it obvious?
Tushingham (chuckling)
Robin (glances at Kermit): You’re the Monitor? How? Why? How are you even alive? I thought Gonzo killed you!
Skeeter (laughs): Gonzo? Kill Kermit? Ha! He’s a weirdo, but he’s no killer! *laughs*
Kermit (tenderly approaches Robin): I’m sorry, Robin. Gonzo didn’t kill me. He wanted me to pose for some kind of old-timey photo, but it took so long I passed out. Gonzo used my puppet double since it wouldn’t breathe.
Tushingham (angrily): Alright, hold it! My brain is going to explode! Kermit, if you’re really just a puppet, then why are you saying you can breathe but this puppet double can’t?
Kermit (looks up at Tushingham): Sir David, the secret of the Muppets isn’t that we’re puppets. It’s that humans are.
Tushingham (shocked): Pardon?
Kermit (sighs, walking up to the form of Puppet Jim and looking up tenderly at him): I met Jim … this Jim … in the fifties. He was a member of the Doll-Making Man Club. He was the first to explain their true nature to me. You see, the hyphen isn’t between “doll” and “making” … it’s between “making” and “man”. Humans didn’t create Muppets. We created them.
Tushingham (incredulously): Argh! Ugh! Why, I don’t, I mean I mean I … I’ve never been so insulted in my entire life!
Robin (in a close-up, with an expression of realization): It’s … insulting.
Kermit (nods): Every living thing wants to know that they’re special. They want to feel alive. They want to believe they have free will and control over their environment. But that isn’t really the case at all. Humans can do so many things we Muppets can’t. We’re either too short, too tall, too flimsy, too solid …. Humans are the real Whatnots … they’re good for just about everything.
Skeeter (nods solemnly): Only a few members of the Doll … *uses quote gesture* Making-Man … *stops gesturing* Club know the real truth. Kermit, or, the Monitor, decided with Jim to boost human self-esteem by making them happy.
Kermit (nods, sniffling): It was our dream.
Skeeter (puts Waldo’s body down on the ground and pats Robin on the shoulder): It’s a dream that gets better the more people you share it with. We believe in them, and then they can believe in themselves. Kermit hired me early on, along with my brother, Scooter. While Scooter takes care of the records and stuff, I am a covert spy, helping Kermit “monitor” the situation for anything that might hurt the dream. *glances at Waldo* Poor kid. I had Kermit cancel Muppet Television as soon as it became clear Waldo thought he was better than all of us. He was going to go public with the truth. Muppet Central would’ve been flamebroiled to a crisp for daring to put humans in their place. We had to do that Behind-the-Scenes episode to pre-empt anything Waldo could do.
Tushingham (sits down, horrified at the revelation): I … I … I just can’t … believe it.
Kermit (places a hand tenderly on Tushingham’s shoulder): Life’s like a movie, Sir David. You know, you write your own ending.
Tushingham (chuckles through his grief): Well, apparently not ….
Kermit: Awww. Don’t be that way. As long as I’m alive, and as long as I have friends who will help with our dream, you’ll always feel special … to us and to yourselves. Even that book tells the story of the Maker forming you out of clay. You’re made out to be just a claymation figurine. And that story was written ages ago. This idea isn’t new. It’s always been around. Ever seen that movie Clash of the Titans? Aren’t humans always portrayed as little chess figures?
Tushingham (his head in his hands): What am I to do now? This wasn’t the answer I was looking for.
Robin (shrugs): I guess real answers never are. Uncle Kermit? What do we do now? Big musical number?
Kermit (shrugs, smirking): Not quite. *looks down at a watch that just happens to be on his wrist now* Hm, wonder where the watch came from. Anyway, we’ve only been doing this movie for about thirty minutes. So, because I’m not really against technology, of course, let’s put this up on Youtube and invite all the users to write their own endings.
Skeeter: Ha! *crosses arms* Well, at least then they can’t gripe we ruined it. *grins*
[An instrumental version of Rainbow Connection plays slowly as everyone exits the room, with Tushingham reluctantly tossing Digit over his shoulder and carrying him out. The only one left is Waldo. Soon, his eyes open, with static overlaying his eyes. Faintly, we hear a very robotic-like voice, similar to Digit’s original one.]
Robotic voice: "I am a machine that would be anything you like. What kind of machine do you want? I can do anything. Machines are better than people. Machines can do anything. I can be an adding machine, subtracting machine, gumball machine, soda pop dispensing machine, jukebox..."
Waldo (as the static continues, but in his voice as the soundtrack silences, singing creepily to the tune of Rainbow Connection): Life’s like the Matrix … we’re all just a program … keep believing … keep pretending … robots know what all that we must do … we keep believing … and we will … love too….
[Fade-out.] THE END?