Gardy- I like your idea of using Kermits, so anyone can now review their films in either stars of Kermits. Here's my next review:
"The Phantom of the Opera" starring Gerry Butler, Emmy Rossum and Pat Wilson. 3
s out of 4
s.
I cannot say a bad thing about this film. It is truly marvelous, in every sense of the word. All the production values- the music, the set design, the acting, the plot, everything- are fantastic.
No doubt you know the Phantom story by now. If you haven't, I'm going to break my own rule and not say what it is, because this film is so fabulous that if you haven't seen it already, you should go out to your Best Buy (or whatever) and immediately pick up a copy.
The music is mainly what the film rests on, as it is, after all, a musical. All of it is performed with a 100-piece orchestra, with occasional overdubs by what sounds like a rock band, or sometimes a synthesiser. The music tracks are laid down fabulously, with grandeur and talent that far surpasses that of the original cast album.
In the vocals, however, the film takes a slight beating. Why? Well, Simon Callow and Ciaran Hinds (the theater owners) are at the very top of the ladder, with dead flawless performances. Just slightly down are Miranda Richardson, Jennifer Ellison and Patrick Wilson (Mad. Giry, Meg Giry and Raoul respectively) with nearly perfect performances. Slightly lower are the two main characters- Emmy Rossum (Christine) and Gerry Butler (Phantom.) Of these two, I'd have to say that Butler provides the better performance. His deep vocals, while often imperfect, provide a good performance of the titular character. Rossum, however, often pierces directly through the air with vocals that could get to annoy you if you overload on them, which I unfortunately did. Dead at the bottom is Margaret Preece (Carlotta), who dubbed actress Minnie Driver's voice. I really hate Italian opera, and so Preece bugs the **** out of me.
The set design is perfect. The costumes are huge and impressive, going over those of the stage versions hand and fist. The cinematography gives the film another beating, however. Far too often is the camera placed at odd angles, providing a strange perspective. Also, the film is sometimes lit too dark, which made me have to strain really hard to see the sets.
Overall, I loved this film. Is there anything wrong with it? Certainly, as no film is perfect. Are the imperfections small when compared to everything that went right? Yup.
Overall- 3/4
s- certainly see it, but think twice if you don't like musicals. Otherwise, be my guest.