Devil's Advocate
Okay...I want to bring up something here just for the sake of discussion. When I first heard about these auditions, I was SUPER MEGA excited. What an opportunity. Then, on Monday night thoughts started creeping into my head.
Last summer I got the HUGE opportunity to work with some of the Muppet performers. It was a dream come true. They are, as you all know, some of the nicest people in the world. So dedicated. So true. So whole heartedly behind the product that is The Muppets.
So as I'm lying in bed the other night thinking about this audition I started thinking about the current Muppet performers and wondered what they thought of these auditions. Now I'm sure Steve and Dave know that they have nothing to fear from me if I audition. They are the pros. But I bet there would be some little part of them that says, "Kermit is appearing at a Mall opening and I'm not doing the voice? What?!"
Now, of course, Disney would do this because they don't want to have pay Steve or Dave to fly out to a mall opening (or whatever public appearance these groups will be going to). They can pay someone else, who does a reasonably good impression of the character to go out and perform instead for a much lower rate, thereby saving money. <sarcasm> And I'm not sure but I think Disney cares about money. I could be wrong.</sarcasm>
To me, and please remember this is only my opinion and I could be wrong, what these auditions do is basically say that it's only the puppet that matters, not the performer. Why would the performer matter when they can have three different troupes of performers performing at the same time?
I believe that it's the performer who makes the character and I don't think this project is fair to the guys who are currently performing these characters. Gonzo is not Gonzo without Dave, etc.
Also, what is the next step after this? In a few years Disney COULD say, "You know we're paying these Muppet performers (Steve, Dave, Bill) X amount of dollars to be in this new Muppet TV show and we have all these folks performing in our Public Appearance groups, who'd jump at the chance to be on TV doing these characters and we'd only have to pay them less than half of what the other guys get. Their voices are close enough." (Please notice I said this is what they COULD do.)
Now I know you may be thinking, "Well they have Bear do shows at the Parks and it's not really the person who does Bear." Yes. But, and correct me if I'm wrong, the person in the show at the Theme park is not actually speaking the part. They are lip syncing to a recorded track done buy the guy who does Bear. This project seems different.
I am not saying people shouldn't audition. I'm just giving folks something to discuss. Heck, I may even go audition still just to audition (though I'm positive after this little post, the job is a sure thing for me). Just something to think about. I'd love to hear your thoughts on this.
Grant