I think the main problem with Elmo IS a matter of quantity over quality. He does have a personality, and he is capable of some funny or at least likable sketches... but when most episodes feature him, then sketches involving him and a celebrity, then Elmo's World... that's a little too much, and a lot of it is basically him personality devoid hosting. I think Kevin does a great job, sure... he is one of my favorite puppeteers. But this kind of over-exposure ruins character. Look at what happened with Pooh. He became more a source of revenue than the lovable character that we remember.
I want to see Elmo EMOTE! I loved him in the Ricky Gervais sketch, he's great whenever Zoe brings up Rocko... but most of the time, he's pretty flat. And it's not the puppeteer's fault... it's the stuff they have him doing. That's why we really should get SW to try abandoning EW one last time, but replacing it with one of the other Elmo based segments. SW had a Elmo's Backyard segment up on their site for a while, and I thought it was quite good. That's the direction they SHOULD take the character... have him interact with others. That's why EW doesn't work for me. He doesn't interact with anything that isn't a CGI or a separately tapes insert.
Exactly! The overexposure is what grates on parents' nerves (and the nerves of us old school fans).
Elmo can be more than a one-note tickle machine, but SW doesn't seem to want that. There have been some moments where Elmo gets angry, scared or frustrated just like a kid would. The Rocko stuff is a great example. So is the "grease fire at Hooper's" segment (see the 40th Anniversary DVD for that). Also, there's the 100% wish-I-taped-that-because-it-was-classic "Happy Caps" episode! Let's face it, Muppets are funny when they freak out. Kermit did it, Grover did it, Fat blue did it, Bert did it and for that golden episode, Elmo did it too.
Kids deal with problems and go through all kinds of emotions all the time. Why not have Elmo do the same? Big Bird has been doing that since what...season 2?
As for EW...I wondered that if SW wanted to do away with it, then just shave off a minute here or there this season, another minute the next season and so on until it's gone. Taking it away all at once, kids will notice. But what about a gradual process?
In EW, Elmo only interacts with Mr. Noodle, who is pretty much a mute Buddy or Jim. Segments like that were done so much better by Luis, Maria, Bob, etc. by using the "sped up camera" technique. Plus, kids learned how to spell a word or learned a shape. What exactly do they learn from Mr. Noodle? How to put on a hat? I understand the whole "kids feel empowered by knowing how to do something that Mr. Noodle doesn't" concept. I got that. But when you watch "Henson's Place", you'll see that Big Bird already served that purpose.
Also..."Let's ask a baby." Why? I can understand it being "cute" or whatever maybe once. But every day for over 12 years?
Don't get me wrong, Kevin is a great performer. I really enjoyed his early work as Hoots. You could just tell within seconds of seeing and hearing him that Hoots was an old jazz owl. you knew Hoots had been playing at clubs for 35 years and just landed on Sesame Street one day. You get the same vibe from Zoot or Floyd.
One thing I wonder is what will happen set-wise. For the longest time, the set had the gritty look that Jon Stone wanted. Then later, Big Bird's doors looked like they were made by Fisher Price, then the gritty look (at least of the doors) came back. What will they do this year?
Convincing John