Mark Filton said:
Ah, Buck Beaver, I don't think you could say all that if you weren't in Canada and being protected by our United States forces next door
You might be in a torture room now if you said that in Kuwait and were captured by Hussein on the border
Ah, Canada-bashing. How quaint.
Mark, I was really offended by this post for a couple of reasons.
First of all, I said what I did because it breaks my heart to see so many Americans losing their lives and their families grieving. I too would personally like to see Hussein offed as quickly as possible (and it sounds like the Iraqis have the same idea) and it's a truly great thing that Iraq has been liberated.
No sane person can suggest that it's right that Saddam Hussein stayed in power. He should have been removed at the end of the last Gulf War. What I personally don't agree with was the way all this happened. It's obvious to everyone (except maybe the folks at Fox News) that there were few, if any weapons of mass destruction. The intelligence that linked Saddam to 9/11 was bad at best and falsified at worst. I also believe that the war in Iraq also has also created an ideal battleground for anti-US terrorists and distracted the world's attention from real threats - al queda and rogue countries that have real weapons of mass destruction like North Korea.
If we're going to get rid of
all the undemocratic terror-supporting states in the world sign me up. Just someone please explain to me why it's necessary to kill thousands in Iraq to remove a tin-pot dictator like Saddam Hussein while we negotiate a peaceful, UN solution to a government of nuclear-armed, hopped-up maniacs who sell terrorists weapons (North Korea).
I was also really offended because your comment kinda suggests that Canada is some kind of miltary wimp - a myth that right wing commentators in the US like to spread. The fact is there is a lot of wrong information about Canada spread on the US news channels unfortunately.
Canada has never been soft on tyrants. Canadians were fighting and dying by the tens of thousands in WW1 and WW2 years before the US decided to enter those wars. Canada didn't fight in Iraq because since WW2 we have a stated policy of not particpating in
any war unless the UN Security Council sanctions it or there is an undisputely
clear and immeadate threat to us or one of our NATO allies. I think Canadians know sometimes you have to fight war. But we also know you kill a lot of people in the process, so if we're going to be mixed up in that we have to be 100% sure those deaths are necessary.
The only major conflicts Canada has sat out since WW2 have been Vietnam and the recent Iraqi war (ironically the two most controversial wars of the past century in America).
We don't just blindly follow the UN either. We fought in the first Gulf War (and would have even without UN permission). When the UN refused to act in Kosvo, Canada joined the independent US-led action there because we believed there was - again - a
clear and immeadate threat to general European security. When the US was attacked on 9/11 Canada was one of the first countries to offer whatever military assistance we could.
It's true that our defense spending here is an embarassment (we seem to be busy spending $$ on pesky liberal things like universal health care
) but fortunately we have a new Prime Minister who has promised to better fund and equip our armed forces.
Despite a real lack of numbers and funding, the Canadian military is heavily engaged in the "war on terror." Our elite anti-terrorist force (Joint Task Force Two) is deployed to aid in the search for al queda terrorists and Osama Bin Laden. CSIS (Canada's own mini-CIA) has been hunting down and arresting suspected "sleeper agents" that may have entered Canada to attack the US and helped foil several terrorist plots against Americans. The Candian Army is commanding the US/NATO force in Afghanistan and we have thousands of troops serving over there, a mission that the White House asked Canada to take on so they could send some of their troops there to fight in Iraq.
So we're not by any means soft on security issues or dictators. We just sometimes take a different approach to national and international security than our US neighbors.
I guess my point here is to be careful not to suggest that Canadians should be lumped in with some of the more self-serving truly anti-American countries in the world.
Oh, that and don't believe everything (ok, anything) you hear on Fox News.