What really gets me is that these people dont seem to understand the concept of liking someone as a villain. You sure can like an absolutely terrible person and not support any of their actions.
As someone who has been a fan of Negaduck since 1991, I agree with this. There's something attractive about a fictional character who is utterly, unrepentantly evil. You don't want anybody to be like Negaduck, or Purple Guy, or Hannibal Lecter in real life, but they can be great characters.
When people make Purple Guy bishounen or hot or sympathetic or in any other way soften him, in my mind they get away from the central point of his character:
He is a serial child murderer. He's not the Purple Guy anymore, he's just someone they dipped in purple paint. I wouldn't slam someone else's art or story over that, though; I just shrug and move on. Fandoms don't need haters. (Pity haters are never in short supply.) *sigh* Poor Rebornica; I did like her art.
I've been drawing
a comic about Springtrap/The Purple Guy, and I gave him a backstory, at least as far as his involvement with the various incarnations of the pizzeria and its mascots go. He's an utter SOB, but as a human he had to play it cool so he could indulge his "hobby" when the opportunity arose. As Springtrap he can let his inner beast out, because he's angry and frustrated and there's no other point to his existence any more. It's an interpretation of FNAF and the characters that I have not seen elsewhere, and I was expecting to take flak from every direction about it, but the response has been overwhelmingly positive. No haters yet, only a few people who want to nitpick me on the number of ghosts or why I didn't include "Balloon Girl." And I'm very amused to notice that since I started a few other people have drawn Purple Guy to resemble my "Killer Bob" homage rather than a bishie or a solid purple man.