Originally posted by murgatoad
Look, people fell in love with Piggy because she ISN'T like a pig. Jim Henson himself once said the key to her popularity is the idea of a beautiful pig. It's an incongruity (look it up), and people love incongruity (see: Cowardly Lion). She's not Babe in a dress, 'kay? Once people see her as merely an absurdity, then that's the end of that character. Hope this explanation helps. Happy to be of service.
Yes, I'm quite aware of what "incongruity" means, thanks.
But the Cowardly Lion was ALSO supposed to be comical, in that this big ferocious lion was such a, well, scaredy cat. The Cowardly Lion and Miss Piggy *are* both incongruities. And if Miss Piggy were slimmed down and sexy, she would no longer be an incongruity.
I'm not saying we're not supposed to like Piggy. We certainly are. But it's with an affectionate laugh, recognizing our own foibles and our own desires to be something other than we are.
I have no desire to see Piggy become a complete laughingstock with no sympathy directed toward her. But I also have no desire to see her become a fashion model without a personality (and if she no longer had to struggle to be glamorous, what personality would she have left?).
Just my $180 million (enough to buy Henson! Woo-hoo!)