Karen,
I hear ya loud and clear. Administrators please feel free to edit my earlier post with Henson contact info (i can't edit it now).
My biggest fear here is that the Henson folks will think "how quaint, they want fraggle DVDs" and then think "hey, this is kids stuff...let's make a cute little compliation "best of" DVD set."
That would be a shame. Fraggle fans deserve the entire series and we deserve to have the episodes in order. If you're aware that Henson folks are reading this thread and that what is discussed here will have some effect on their decision making process, super!
Another thought I've had is that once an outside-vendor has been established to have the rights to press the discs (like Time Life) it may be a good idea to let *them* know we want the series in order. When I called henson and talked about getting all the muppet shows on DVD they kept saying "That's not in our hands...Time Life makes all the decisions about that."
I just don't want to risk another situation like we have with the Muppet Show or South Park where we get stuck with "best of" collections and that's it. Fraggle Rock is a show that develops as a series that one ought to be able to experience in order and every episode is worth watching...and worth owning on DVD.
This has been a dream of mine for years and I really don't want some "marketing" guy who's never even watched the show to hand me a best-of DVD!
Anyhow, here's some of my ideas about how to best-serve the Fraggle Fan with a DVD release:
- The long-term goal should be to make the entire series available with all episodes in order of release.
- The DVDs could be single or dual-layer discs and either packaged individually for @$20 or in season sets. This would let consumers buy the discs they are interested in for those out there not intending to purchase the whole set (if the Muppet Show and South Park DVDs are an indication it's a good bet most fans will buy *all* the DVDs they can...Time Life is contantly on back-order with their Muppet Show set).
- Music Music Music. The incredible music of Fraggle Rock is one of its greatest strengths. It should be treated as such on the DVD. Every episode has a "featured" song or two (Sail Away, The Moon Song, Our Melody). At the end of each episode or during the episode as an alternate audio track, users should be able to select to hear the pure stereo-studio mix. This would be amazing if it happened. Each DVD would be like purchasing a CD with the studio song mixes! Linear PCM should be the audio format for recording any "music" tracks. 20 bit 48 kHz resolution would be wonderful.
- The stereo mix for the show, if it uses dolby digital compression for bandwidth reasons, should *not* use 2.0 DD at the 192 kbps data-rate. It sounds really aweful and all it takes is a cursory glance at any DVD forum to find that most people prefer the sound of the PCM on laserdisc or even the analog stereo on hi-fi VHS to 2.0 DVD at the 192 kbps rate!!!
If 2.0 DD is used, it should be at a higher rate like 348 kbps which would do a much better job at preserving fidelity. It's really REALLY important that our Fraggle Music sound as good as it can.
- Cool things like any documentaries or interviews/commentary when appropriate would be awesome too!
thanks for listening