Just popped in to offer my two cents. I'm not a fan of reboots in general, and it's very rare that I'll find one I actually like. I've found one I actually liked. I like the fact that Karen Prell and Dave Goelz returned, and I do have to say that the new voices of Mokey, Gobo, and Wembley are great. Very close to being exact matches, actually. Matter of fact, I almost thought Cotterpin was being voiced by Kathryn Mullins before I looked it up. The writing is actually good, and it doesn't have to rely on gross-out humor (of which I am not a huge fan of). Everyone is in-character, which is a plus. The Traveling Matt postcards feel like they pick up right where they left off.
However, I have to be a little nitpicky about some things.
Let's take the new Doc for example. I like her as a character, I think she's really fun, and I love her interactions with Sprocket, but I just don't like that they named her Doc (yeah, I know it's a stupid complaint, but I just don't think the name fits her). I did love this one part with her in the pilot, though, when Gobo's talking about how awful and terrible "the monster" was, and there's Doc, tickling Sprocket's tummy and saying in baby-talk, "Who's my little peanut butter biscuit boy?" (well, I thought that was kinda funny).
I'm also not too crazy about Marjory the Trash Heap's voice. Yes, I am aware that, with Jerry Nelson gone, they have to make do, and his characters aren't going to sound exactly like they once did, but it just doesn't sound right to me. Not to mention Philo's voice sounds more like someone impersonating John Stephanson more than Dave Goelz (John Stephanson was the man who voiced Philo on the Fraggle Rock animated series). I also think the Architect Doozer needs a little more work, but that's just me.
I'm not too happy with Mokey's new hairstyle. I thought she looked better before. I kind of like her new dress, and her new necklace, but not her hair. That, and she just looks like a completely different character to me.
But other than these nitpicks (and the fact that I've only gotten up to episode four so far), I am definitely liking this. Hope they release a soundtrack, or at least a way to get the new songs on my iPod. And, if it gets more seasons, I hope they bring Lou back! (for those of you who don't know, Lou Fraggle was a character in the episode "We Love You Wembley" from the original series.)