Scott: The "Lime in the Coconut" number that you described was in the Kenny Rogers episode. It was also featured in several of the compilation videos.
Camilla: The Muppet Show was in the late '70s, and "Call Me Al" wasn't recorded till the mid-80's.
Gorgon Heap: Wow. A fan of the first-season episodes, are we?
Someone (sorry, I forgot who): The episode set in the train station was the Loretta Lynn episode.
I really like the Star Wars episode since I'm a Star Wars fan too...but seeing it now that I'm older, there are some dry spots in it. Still a lot of fun, but there are a few episodes that are more consistent throughout. My personal favorite is the Linda Rondstadt episode. Great music; a strong, funny plotline that affects the whole show (a jealous Piggy locks Kermit in a chest to keep him away from Linda); Linda looks great (in the days before her unfortunate weight troubles; and when Linda sings "When I grow too old to dream, I'll have you to remember..." (a clip used in the 30-year celebration) I can't help but think of Jim and cry. Beautiful.
Plus, when Kermit is missing, the Swedish Chef does the introduction. How can you beat that?
("Leenda Roonstaat! Yayyyyy!")
In fact, in general, I find that the 5th season episodes are stronger than the rest of the episodes. The backstage plot sreally push the episodes forward and affect the onstage action a lot more. In earlier episodes, the backstage plot would be kind of removed from the rest of the show, or else be surprisingly abandoned altogether. The writing started to move towards more plot-driven shows in later seasons (Linda Lavin, Phyllis George, Liza Minelli, etc.), and in Season 5 they really hit the mark almost all the time (Gene Kelly, Marty Feldman, Brooke Shields, Hal Linden, etc.). It's kind of a shame that Jim pulled the plug on the show when he did...he seemed to think they were all out of ideas. IMHO, they had just really hit their stride.
I'm somewhat relieved. I hadn't seen TMS in ages until I started getting the Time-Life stuff , so I thought I was rather ignorant of what the best episodes were. But I've seen most of the episodes that people have mentioned here. Whew!
Can anyone else recommend any more episodes that aren't on the Time-Life list?