I like the Orange Gold Guy Smiley-type best, as well as the small Hot Pink Anything Muppet used for Prairie Dawn, the Busby Twins, Betty Lou and the Three Little Pigs.
It also seems that Frank Oz and Jerry Nelson used the Large Lavender Live Hand muppet a LOT. I mean, the Count used to be made out of that type of Anything Muppet, and the Amazing Mumford and Lord Chatterly and Rodeo Rosie come from that pattern, and as for Frank Oz, his Aladdin and Little Miss Muffet and Harvey Kneeslapper are Large Lavender Live Hand Anything Muppets too.
I also noticed that the Pointy-headed Green Anything Muppet is used a lot for non-Kermit frogs, such as the Sleeping Beauty frog, the London Frog, etc. It was also used for the original version of the tortoise (I can tell because of its pointy-looking head). Later versions use a different puppet without a pointy head (it might be a Small Green Anything Muppet.)
Rabbits on "Sesame Street" (until at least the late 80s) were usually made out of the Lavender or Large Lavender Live Hand Anything Muppet, such as the Hare in the Aesop fable, Howie and Captain Vegetable (all lavender) and that Easter Bunny in that News Flash about the holiday mix-up (which is obviously a Large Lavender Live Hand puppet).
Another thing I noticed is that, except for Ernie and Bert and Bruno, almost every other human Muppet character on "Sesame Street" is (or was originally) made out of an Anything Muppet. I mean, if you look at a human Muppet on the show, it could be either a Fat Blue, a Pointy-Headed Green, a Lavender, a Pumpkin-type, etc. Heck, even Kingston Livingston the Third was made out of an Anything Muppet! (the rarely-seen brown type)