Cookie Monster eats Ernie's Rubber Duckie??!

[Daffyfan4ever]

Thanks for bringing that up. I remember the Miami Mice sketch, but vaguely. I didn't recall him saying that Bert was the one that broke rubber duckie, but it's been so long since I've seen it, I don't know.

 

[CBPuppets]

What if Cookie monster begins to squeak like Ernie's Rubber Duckie?

 

[The Shoe Fairy]

I don't see why he hasn't. "Oh OM NOM NOM NOM oh it so good. Me love yellow ducky cookie!"

 

[ISNorden]

The lettering on a cookie seemed to survive Cookie Monster's teeth and digestive fluids, in one of his non-Prairie "Letter of the Day" segments. He'd eaten one with an X on it, then admitted "Me feel tremendous guilt!" over destroying the thing. When a nurse came in with an X-ray machine, her picture of Cookie Monster's insides revealed an intact red X floating around where his stomach should be. Granted, that's as close as Sesame Street "canon" gets to having a whole cookie survive the process...and granted, rubber ducks (even in a fictional world) aren't made of the same stuff as that letter-frosting. Still, Ernie's never lost his duckie to the monster's appetite, either on the show or in a book...which is a Good Thing, since whatever Cookie eats is typically gone forever. (It'd be hard to replace, too; I've read that the style of duck Ernie's owned since Season 1 isn't being made anymore.)

 

[Beauregard]

It would be giggleworthy if Cookie ate the duck and started squeaking. But he really would have to burp it back up again...or there'd be many sad fans.

 

[OldSchoolFan]

something tells me there WAS a skit involving cookie monster eating rubber duckie. i dont know why but i feel like there was one...