Well, I'm not going to let my fondness for a certain Muppet blur my judgement on whether Lips should be an all-new sculpt or a retooled Zoot or anybody.
Despite the obvious appeal that Lips has with most of us on here, (and just a warning, I'm going to play devil's advocate for a second or two) there are still a few factors Palisades no doubt will consider...
1. If Lips is a strong enough character to be made available in a normal assortment.
2. If not, and let's say an alternative would be to offer him via the Collector's Club or ToyFare or wherever, if there is enough mass interest there to warrant the cost of sculpting an all-new figure as opposed to treating it like a variant figure.
Hasbro has recently been mix-and-matching different parts to construct figures of new Star Wars characters, and in some cases the quality (or lack thereof) shows. I would hate to see Palisades go that route in the future (save, of course, for a head sculpt for a variant or something).
Let me put it this way: If Lips becomes a regular release figure, then I would most like to see him done as a completely new sculpt. However, if that cannot be done and Lips becomes some oddball exclusive somewhere, and there are really insurmountable circumstances, then I wouldn't be totally peeved if Lips's body is a Zoot body with a PVC poncho over it.
But hopefully, that won't happen unless the line really takes a turn for the worst. I guess it's all up to how much we support it.
If I may throw in a little side question here. Ken, I'm not sure how much you may know about marketing feasibility and such, but speaking totally hypothetically, could the line survive as just a Diamond Distribution product, or is it imperative to need a "name" store like an EB, a Suncoast, a TRU, or a (super secret mystery retailer)? I mean, what would be the worst case scenario for the line to continue?
(and I'm not trying to scare anybody...was just something I have been wondering)