Docnzhoss said:
Shemp has his moments, but Curly-Joe was atrocious. Even the Three Stooges cartoons suffer his lack of personality.
Actually, Curly Joe, I'd say he was OK, at least compaired to Joe Besser. He just didn't want to be there, and it showed! I watched 2 of them, and it seemed more like the 2 Stooges with Joe Besser. he was always off doing his own thing, he didn't get involved with much of the slapstick, and the other stooges didn't like him. In fact, Moe had to put all his abuse on Larry to make up for it. I'm bad with titles, but there was a remake of a Curly episode with Joe. There was no point in making it. It's the one where Moe has a stress disorder, and to take a break and relax, they bring him to a cabin in the woods, and a Bear eats all their food. All the abuse Moe did to Curly in the original was now gien to Larry. It's like he had to pull double duty on these ones.
But Shemp? I didn't like him much at first, but after a while, I think he's my close second favorite with Curly.
Speaking of remakes of Curly, did anyone notice that episode where Shemp, Moe, and Larry own a diner (I can't remember it much)? When they were settling down to have clam chowdah, Moe did Curly's exact bit? A nice little tribute to him, I think.